Bottom Line

Altra’s flagship trail shoe continues to offer rugged, zero-drop performance that keeps your feet comfortable without crunching your toes. This newest version of the Lone Peak aims to fix durability issues that affected earlier models by adding no-sew overlays to a 100% Ripstop mesh upper.

This might be the first edition since the original Lone Peak where the upper’s durability matches the rest of the shoe. However, the new upper fabric left our feet feeling a bit stuffy on hot days. 

Those seeking ample room in the toe box will find it here, though some might find even the standard width too spacious. We sized down in the 9+ to achieve a secure fit in both the heel and midfoot and used lace locking techniques. However, we still felt our feet slide around in the shoe even when wearing thicker socks.

To see many other options, check out our guide to the best trail running shoes for women.

How We Tested

We took the Lone Peak 9+ on training runs in New Hampshire’s White Mountains before a section hike on the Appalachian Trail.

They handled bike trails, rocks, and singletrack with ease. The Megagrip greatly enhances traction compared to previous models. After a series of disappointing updates, the 9+ is a strong choice from Altra Running.

Traction

The biggest upgrade to the Lone Peak 9+ is in the outsole. The MaxTrac outsole of the 8 was largely disappointing, so replacing it with Vibram Megagrip has significantly improved the shoe’s performance. The 9+ grips wet rocks and slippery surfaces much better than the 8, and we felt secure on slabby rocks during test runs and hikes in New Hampshire’s White Mountains. Additionally, the luggy tread provided solid grip on muddy trails and dirt singletrack. 

These improvements earned the Lone Peak 9+ more points in our view and made us feel secure and confident in a wide range of conditions instead of hesitating on tricky terrain. The Lone Peak 9+ performs well on rugged trails whether wet or dry. Hikers and trail runners will find them offer better traction than previous models and worth the higher price.

comfort

The Lone Peak 9+ provides moderate cushioning thanks to Altra’s EGO midsole foam. We found this shoe to feel softer than many others in the category, improving comfort without sacrificing ground feel. Even with a modest 25mm stack height, we felt ample cushion on roots and rocks. They were also comfortable on mixed runs that included bike paths and gravel roads.

However, the lack of arch support in the Lone Peak left us feeling flat and wishing for more support in the midfoot as we logged miles. This isn’t new to the 9+ and remains an ongoing issue with this shoe. Fans of zero-drop footwear will be happy to see that this feature remains unchanged. But if you’re not used to the zero-drop platform, be prepared for potential adjustments in your calves and tendons as your body adapts. We prefer the more minimal drop (4mm) shoes, and it always takes a while to get used to the “flatness” of the Lone Peak when we wear them.

Like previous models, we found the regular width to be a bit too roomy, even though we typically need wide width in other brands. The upgraded upper reduces some of the swimming feeling we experienced with the 8, but we also went down half a size. People with average or narrower feet might find this an issue and should consider trying other options.

Weight

Despite using a lighter foam than in previous models, the Lone Peak 9+ actually weighs more than the 8. However, we didn’t notice much difference when we were running. Overall, the Lone Peak continues to strike a good balance between comfort and weight, thanks to a squishy midsole and weights that fall right in the middle of the spectrum for trail runners.

Our testers found that even during long training runs, they had no problems picking up their feet. The weight difference in these isn’t a significant enough change to impact their overall performance. Their moderate weight offers a lower fatigue factor, which makes them a good choice for backpacking or thru-hiking where the weight of footwear really matters.

Durability

Altra has taken steps with every new release to address the durability concerns in the upper that have plagued the Lone Peak for several iterations. In this update, they may have finally succeeded. The 9+ has a 100% RPET ripstop mesh upper and upgraded no-sew overlays. Together, these seem to have created a durable trail shoe that won’t fall apart on the sides before the midsole begins to break down. 

During our testing, we didn’t notice any significant damage to the uppers, and fortunately, no durability issues arose during our runs. If Altra has finally addressed the upper durability problems, the Lone Peak 9+ could provide good value for trail runners and backpackers alike, even with the higher price. 

A potential durability issue stems from excessive lateral movement in the forefoot that some users may experience due to the shoe’s roominess. This movement puts extra stress on the sides of the upper. Repeated impact could potentially cause problems where the upper connects to the outsole. Runners who find the toe box too loose but still want room for their toes might want to consider the Topo Traverse instead.

Breathability

The downside of upgrading the mesh to boost durability is that breathability has decreased. Our feet felt stuffy even after short outings in warmer weather. This isn’t a new issue, as we also experienced it with the 8. We had hoped the 9+ would provide a more breathable solution to the durability problem.

Still, this isn’t a deal breaker. The upper remains reasonably breathable, and our feet never developed hot spots or blisters. Those who train in hot and humid conditions might want to look for an option with better airflow, such as the Saucony Peregrine 14.

Responsiveness

While some wider shoes can feel bulky, the Lone Peak 9+ feels reasonably agile on moderate trails, though narrow trails and technical spots were harder to navigate. We felt less secure on tight turns because of the extra room in the toe box. This added lateral movement in the toe box repeatedly made us feel unstable in the forefoot, especially during quick turns or rocky sections.

Still, we liked being able to feel connected to the trail during our runs, and those seeking that connection will be happy with the Lone Peak 9+.

Should You Buy the Women’s Altra Lone Peak 9+?

If you’re looking for shoes that easily accommodate wider forefeet or if you need a high-volume fit, the Lone Peak 9+ could be a good choice. Those who struggle to find shoes that are spacious enough, battle blisters between their toes, or experience discomfort from pressure points caused by bunions will find these shoes offer the right amount of room. 

The traction and cushion are both moderate, making them practical for a wide range of trail users. Those accustomed to a higher drop might have difficulty adjusting to the zero-drop platform without injury.

The Lone Peak 9+ is a reliable choice whether you’re hitting the trails for a run or going on a thru-hike. Its versatility offers good value for those seeking a trail shoe that can handle both running and hiking.

What Other Women’s Trail Runners Should You Consider?

If the Lone Peak 9+ isn’t for you, check out these similar trail runners that offer plenty of room for the toes.

Saucony Peregrine 15 Review: Check out this Editor’s Pick if you’re looking for a minimal drop trail shoe that offers room for your toes while keeping a more traditional profile.

Hoka Speedgoat 6 Review: If you’re looking for a minimal shoe with more traction and durability, check out this former Editor’s Pick. These shoes are at home on rugged trails and have even more room in the foot box than the Lone Peak 8.

Brooks Cascadia 18 Review: If you’re looking for plenty of toe room, a more standard drop, and more durability, these trail runners may be just the ticket. They are available in two widths.

Bottom Line

If you’re on the hunt for a versatile trainer that performs well in dry conditions and on smooth trails, consider the Fresh Foam Hierro X v9 from New Balance. It offers great value for both runners and hikers seeking performance and cushioning.

It has a unique combination of Vibram-coated micro-lugs and maximum cushioning. These shoes are available in several widths, and version 9 offers several great color options in muted tones

During our testing, we found these shoes to be incredibly springy and responsive. We took them on hikes and runs in Monadnock State Park in New Hampshire while training for an Appalachian Trail section hike and beach recovery runs after that trek.

One thing to note is that, while most people will find that there is plenty of room for toe splay in the wide width, the toe box in version 9 is slightly more restrictive than earlier versions. Our testers found that their toes were hitting the top of the shoe in addition to having a bit less width. 

However, the highly breathable upper keeps your feet cool and comfortable and the plush ankle cushioning adds an extra layer of comfort on longer outings. Find out more in our guide to the best trail running shoes for women.

Traction

The Hierro 9 has a Vibram Megagrip outsole and features a revised Traction Lug pattern. Together, these updates significantly boost their performance on wet rocks and dirt trails compared to previous models. 

Our testers took these on several training runs and hikes in New Hampshire’s Monadnock State Park and were impressed with their traction on a wide variety of terrain.

This updated version has deeper lugs than previous models, which we really noticed on muddy singletrack. We experienced much more stability and grip in these conditions.

Additionally, the midsole foam contains 3% bio-based material, making these a slightly more eco-friendly choice compared to others on the market. Unlike earlier models, we missed the outsole’s exceptionally sticky surface, but the Megagrip still provided excellent grip on slick surfaces. This shoe offers good versatility whether you’re running smooth paths or tackling muddy, rocky singletrack, allowing you to focus on exploring rather than your footwear.

comfort

With a maximum cushion midsole, the Hierro X v9 is an extremely comfortable shoe on any type of trail—whether you’re tackling rocky paths or smooth singletrack. The lightweight mesh upper is stretchy and comfortable, though we found the 9 to be somewhat more restrictive than the 8, with our toes occasionally hitting the top of the upper.

You might want to go up half a size or choose a different width from what you wore in the 8 to allow for more toe splay. Despite this, the Hierro v9 remains very comfortable. With three width options available, it’s easy to get a perfect fit. 

We appreciated the ample laces that allowed us to do a lace lock for steep grades and this edition has woven laces that are stretchy offering more comfort without constriction and less length to trip over without compromising function. The generous ankle cushioning kept chafing at bay, allowing us to focus on our run. 

During our test runs, we logged miles on a variety of terrain, from dirt trails to muddy slopes, paved bike paths to technical singletrack and beach runs in sand. Throughout it all, the overall comfort level remained consistently high.

Weight

The Hierro X v9 is slightly lighter than previous models, thanks in part to a 2mm reduction in heel-toe drop. This brings them in line with most models on the market, making them a solid choice for most trail runners.

These shoes felt light and airy during our runs, and our feet remained fresh even after a long training session. The combination of maximum cushion and lightweight materials creates a versatile shoe that is well worth the investment for those seeking footwear that can effortlessly transition between different trail types. 

Durability

While the Hierro X v9 is designed with lightweight mesh uppers they withstood the rigors of the trail—showing no signs of wear even after exposure to trail debris and abrasion during our testing.

What’s more, the strategic protective overlays on the toe box and the sides, provide reinforcement in common high-wear areas, helping to ensure that these shoes will last. The upper mesh on the 9 is also tighter than previous models, which should increase long term performance. 

However, unlike the 8, which had a minimally exposed midsole, the v9 features an exposed channel that is prone to trapping debris.

Unfortunately, we believe this could decrease the shoe’s overall durability. Small sticks and sharp rocks scraped and punctured the Fresh Foam X on several of our runs. That said, if your main training trails don’t have much sharp debris, it shouldn’t be a big problem.

Breathability

Finding the right balance between breathability and durability is key to a great trail running shoe. New Balance has achieved that with the Hierro X v9 by creating a shoe with a slightly tighter mesh upper that remains highly breathable. 

Even during intense workouts during a summer heatwave, our feet stayed cool and comfortable, never soggy. The ample ventilation in the Hierro is one of our favorite features on this shoe. 

However, it’s worth noting that because it is a highly padded shoe, the interior cushioning was a bit slow to dry just as it is in previous models, which we experienced running at the beach. While it meant damp shoes on the next day’s outing, it wasn’t a deal breaker and didn’t cause issues with chafing or blisters.

Responsiveness

The Fresh Foam X midsole offers plenty of energy return regardless of your pace, making these a great choice for a daily trainer and race day shoe. We have been very happy with the responsiveness of such a highly cushioned shoe. Often, the thick sole causes us to lose contact with the ground or feel like we’re on stilts. The Hierro v9 doesn’t do either. 

During our runs on various trails in New Hampshire, we found them to be agile and provide adequate ground feel and stability for more technical sections, including rooty terrain and rocky slopes. On our beach runs, they offered excellent flotation in the sand and solid energy return on the hard-packed sand. On connecting bike paths and roads, they provided a fast ride and didn’t feel like the lugs were “catching,” as some trail shoes do on pavement.

New Balance has addressed our only real concern, which was that previous models felt a bit sloppy in the heel. The 9’s offer a very secure fit that gave us more agility throughout our runs.

Although the plush cushioning reduces ground feel and some runners may desire a more connected trail experience, the Hierro 9 effectively balances comfort and performance, making it a highly responsive shoe for those who want more cushion underfoot.

Should You Buy the New Balance Women’s Fresh Foam Hierro X V9?

We found these shoes to be a solid trail offering from a reliable brand. Providing cushy comfort, decent traction, and terrain versatility in three widths, the Hierro X v9 checks many boxes—appealing to a variety of runners and hikers.

Those searching for a versatile trail shoe that won’t break the bank will find these to be a solid choice. If your training involves a variety of surfaces and trail types, these will offer great value as they can handle it all.

However, if you mainly run on technical mountain trails, you might find them less aggressive than you need. Runners seeking a more performance-oriented fit for improved agility, deep mud-lugging for muddy terrain, or increased ground feel should look at other options. 

Overall, these shoes provide a comfortable experience and are a great choice whether you’re accelerating on a trail run or just taking a casual walk through the woods.

What Other Women’s Trail Runners Should You Consider?

If the New Balance Fresh Foam Hierro X v9 isn’t for you, check out these similar trail runners that share similar characteristics.

Hoka Speedgoat 6 Review: If you’re looking for an even wider toe box and more traction, check out this former Editor’s Pick. These shoes are at home on rugged trails and have the most room in the footbox of everything we tested. Choose from two widths.

Brooks Catamount 4 Review: If you’re looking for a more performance fit that’s designed to go fast, slip into a pair of these. Equally at home on trail and hardpack, these trail runners marry maximum cushion with durable traction.

Nike Pegasus 5 Review: If you’re looking for a responsive shoe that can go from road to trail and back again slip into a pair of these. These trail runners have a slimmer fit and are designed to make everyone feel fast.

Bottom Line

The Altra Experience Wild 2 trail shoe is an affordable, versatile choice with plenty of cushioning. Diverging from the traditional zero-drop, Altra offers a shoe that balances support and comfort with a minimal 4mm drop, making it even more appealing to a broader range of runners.

During our test hikes in New Hampshire’s Monadnock State Park, even in the sweltering East Coast heat and humidity, the breathable upper and spacious toe box kept our feet cool and comfortable.

We tested a variety of trails, from soft pine needle paths to rocky scrambles, and the Experience Wild 2 performed well on all of them. The built-in gaiter trap is a useful feature for those who prefer to wear gaiters for trail debris. The MaxTrac outsole provides excellent traction except in wet conditions.

Our only concern is that the lightweight upper may not be very durable, despite overlay reinforcements. Overall, the Experience Wild 2 is a great value trail shoe that appeals to a wide range of users at an affordable price.

To see many other options, check out our guide to the best trail running shoes for women.

How We Tested

We tested the Experience Wild 2 on trails in New Hampshire’s Monadnock State Park, including the slabby scramble to the summit.

We also logged miles on packed gravel and singletrack while recovering from a long backpacking trip on the Appalachian Trail.

Traction

The Altra Experience Wild 2 features a MaxTrac outsole and deep lugs for excellent traction across various terrain types. We tested these shoes on everything from muddy trails to the slabby rock ascent of New Hampshire’s Mount Monadnock and were impressed with their consistent performance. While slightly less grippy on wet rocks and boardwalks, they still outperformed most comparable models. Even on the steepest slab ascents, we felt securely connected to the rock. 

The Experience Wild 2 performed well on moderate terrain, losing some traction in very muddy conditions, but this wasn’t a dealbreaker. In fact, the slightly less aggressive lugs make it a versatile trail runner, especially if your routes include paved or gravel surfaces, since it doesn’t “catch” on smoother surfaces like more aggressive tread might.

comfort

The comfort category truly distinguishes the Altra Experience Wild 2 from similar models. The thick cushioning provides plush comfort underfoot without being overly high. Additionally, Altra has added a minimal heel-to-toe drop (4mm) to this model, making it more comfortable for a wider range of wearers compared to their classic zero-drop platform.

The midfoot fits more snugly than other similar models, offering a secure fit that is never sloppy while still allowing plenty of room for toes to spread out. Most runners will find the regular width to be more than sufficient, as it’s already wider than a typical women’s shoe, which is beneficial since the Experience Wild 2 is not available in wide width like other Altra trail runners.

Weight

The weight of the Altra Experience Wild 2 is fairly average among the trail runners we tested. This is impressive given the thickness of the midsole and the spaciousness of the toe box.

The use of ultralightweight molded EVA foam gives max cushion without a weight penalty keeping your feet fresh even on long days. Even after an all day romp on the state park trails, we hardly noticed we were wearing shoes at all.

Durability

While the super lightweight materials help keep your feet from getting fatigued on long efforts, they can also be vulnerable to damage from trail debris and rocky terrain. Altra has added TPU overlays to the Experience Wild 2 upper, along with a sturdy toe rand, to address this issue.

We found these features perfect for the rugged terrain of New Hampshire trails, but we were slightly skeptical that the overlays alone would be sufficient. Blowouts around the upper/midsole attachment point have been a common problem with Altra shoes over the years. However, even after dozens of challenging miles, the Experience Wild 2 shows no signs of wear in that area. 

Breathability

The Experience Wild 2 is a highly breathable trail runner that kept our feet cool and ventilated on a sweltering day in a July heatwave on the East Coast. Even when wearing them with thicker socks to fill some of the extra space, our feet never felt swampy.

The mesh upper allowed moisture to wick away while moving and helped disperse heat build-up easily. Although this might reduce durability, we found it to be a worthwhile trade-off for intense workouts in the heat–especially on less demanding terrain where snags weren’t a concern. If you often run in hot, humid conditions, this shoe has you covered.

Responsiveness

We found the rocker-style platform of the Experience Wild 2 to genuinely help us pick up the pace on our runs. The lightweight foam was never cumbersome underfoot, and we felt surprisingly agile in such a well-cushioned shoe.

The high level of cushioning protected our feet without compromising our connection to the ground. We felt nimble even on rooty terrain and stable despite the stack height.

Our only real complaint is that the shoe is designed for smooth, fast movements and can be a bit harder to maneuver when you need to slow down on very technical terrain. However, having a shoe built for speed is never really an issue, and the Experience Wild 2 will definitely give you a boost.

Should You Buy the Altra Experience Wild 2?

Runners looking for a smooth, fast ride on mild to moderate trails will find the Altra Experience Wild 2 to be a top performer. The shoe provides ample room in the toe box paired with a more secure midfoot, which some may find slightly snug.

However, the average runner will see these as the Goldilocks of fit—not too wide, not too narrow in the right spots. The high cushioning, rocker-style platform, and minimal 4mm drop all help increase your pace and reduce fatigue.

Plus, the highly breathable mesh upper makes this a great trainer for hot weather. Its lower-than-average price adds to its value as an all-arounder. However, those seeking an extra-wide fit, more volume in the midfoot, or running on highly technical trails may want to look elsewhere.

What Other Women’s Trail Runners Should You Consider?

If the Altra Experience Wild 2 isn’t the shoe for you, check out these similar trail runners that combine performance cushioning with trail approved traction.

Topo MTN Racer Review: An Editor’s Pick, this trail shoe is ideal for technical terrain, offering aggressive traction and exceptional cushioning.

Hoka Speedgoat 6 Review: If you’re looking for an even wider shoe, slip into a pair of these. With excellent trail traction and maximum cushion these shoes are a perennial favorite on trail.

New Balance Fresh Foam Hierro x v9 Review: Looking for a Vibram grip with maximum cushion? These shoes will take you from dry trails to wet pavement with ease.

Bottom Line

The addition of the Traverse to the Topo lineup is a huge win for long-distance backpackers and FKTers. We’ve used the Topo Terraventure for a long time, but the new Traverse is now our go-to because it combines the best qualities of the Terraventure—such as durability and a roomy toe box—with a more breathable upper, a closed-cell insole, and extra cushioning, making it the ultimate rugged trail shoe.

On our backpacking trip in New Hampshire’s White Mountains, the shoe performed exceptionally well on all trail types. It also drained quickly and dried out rapidly after river fords and boggy sections.

Despite being a lighter mesh, the durable upper resisted damage from rocky terrain, while keeping our feet cool and dispersing moisture buildup. The Vibram Megagrip on the outsole provided excellent traction on various surfaces.

Our only caveats are that the gaiter compatibility isn’t universal and that, for the first few miles, the toe box felt a little tight before loosening up.

To see all the trail runners we tested, check out our guide to the best trail running shoes for women.

How We Tested

We first encountered the Traverse at the Appalachian Trail Days festival in Damascus, VA, where we had the chance to try it on for the first time. The reps explained how the shoe was designed with thru-hikers and long-distance runners in mind.

We experienced this attention to detail firsthand during our section hike of the AT in New England, through New Hampshire and into Maine, as well as on training runs for our upcoming backpacking trip in the Pyrenees.

Traction

The Topo Athletic Traverse features an aggressive lug pattern with deep lugs and a sticky Vibram Megagrip outsole, making it an excellent trail shoe for almost every type of terrain. We tested it on a section of the Appalachian Trail, as well as during several hikes and runs in Pennsylvania. Whether the trail was muddy, slick, dirt, or rocky, the Traverse never left us feeling unsure. 

The average day on the Appalachian Trail in the White Mountains includes some hands-on scrambling, steep slabby rock, muddy or boggy trail, and slippery plank bog logs. The Traverse provided us with excellent traction and stability on all of these surfaces.

Unlike most other trail shoes, the Traverse was designed primarily for hiking, which makes them highly versatile. Those who spend long days in the mountains will find these to be the perfect companion, whether they are navigating technical terrain or muddy trails.

comfort

Topo Athletic offers shoes with an anatomical toe box for great comfort and room for toe splay and swelling during long, hot efforts, including the new Traverse. Our testers found the toe box in this model to be slightly more restrictive than other Topo shoes and noticed a pinch point in the widest part of their forefeet during the first few miles. That irritation eventually subsided, but we recommend sizing up half a size from your usual Topo size for extra room.

It’s worth noting that while the toe box provides plenty of wiggle room, the midfoot and heel fit more snugly. This offers a comfortable space in the toes without feeling sloppy, though those with high-volume feet seeking width throughout might prefer the Altra Lone Peak or Hoka Speedgoat.

Besides that, the moderate stack height and firm foam offered great cushioning without losing ground feel. The rock plate in the forefoot prevented our feet from getting battered on the constant rocks and roots of the Appalachian Trail.

Weight

At just over a pound per pair, the Topo Athletic Traverse falls right within the average weight range for trail runners. They strike a balance between rugged durability and aggressive traction, with moderate cushioning and rock protection, all while keeping the weight low—making them a great choice for long days.

The Traverse is built for thru-hikers and FKT setters, as well as anyone putting in long days in the mountains. That group needs shoes that perform without extra weight, and these shoes deliver. Even after 20+ mile days on the Appalachian Trail, our feet didn’t feel heavy or bogged down. 

Durability

One of the things we love most about Topo Athletic shoes is their incredible durability. The Traverse continues this tradition. Even after logging dozens of miles on rocky, root-filled trails, they show very little wear.

We appreciate the durable mesh that combines breathability with strength, as well as the generous overlays in high-abrasion areas that add a second layer of protection. Despite the side abrasion from rocks, the Traverse did not blow out on the side or suffer any tearing, unlike many comparable shoes on the market.

Additionally, the full-coverage Vibram Megagrip outsole protects the midsole from debris, and the toe rand and extensive bumper shield the foot and toebox from damage. We were satisfied with the overall protection the shoe provided and its durability after many miles of rugged terrain.

Breathability

Although not the most breathable mesh, the Topo Athletic Traverse effectively dispersed heat and moisture enough to keep our feet comfortable, even on the hottest and most humid days. We found the slightly less breathable mesh to be a worthwhile trade-off for its remarkable durability; however, those not tackling very rugged trails or recreating in hot climates might want to consider other options.

Additionally, we were pleased with how quickly the Traverse drained after being submerged in river fords on the Appalachian Trail and how fast the shoe’s interior dried. Topo designed the insole with a closed-cell construction to be less absorbent, which we considered a major advantage on the consistently wet AT.

Responsiveness

Despite their hiking-forward construction, runners will still find the Traverse to be a versatile trail shoe suitable for nearly any type of terrain. This hybrid shoe offers plenty of responsiveness with a firm yet plush midsole that provides ample energy return. Our testers found it to have just the right amount of cushion to keep our feet fresh without sacrificing ground feel.

The Traverse felt nimble, unlike a lot of hiking forward designs, and our testers were pleased with its versatility for both long section hikes on the Appalachian Trail and daily trail runs.

While we did miss some of the rocker motion that helps create a smoother gait, the Traverse did not feel flat or clunky like other low-top hikers. Topo Athletic has done an excellent job of strengthening a trail running shoe without sacrificing responsiveness. Those who switch between trail running and hiking will find a lot of value in the Traverse as a shoe that excels in both roles.

Should You Buy the Women’s Topo Athletic Traverse?

Long-distance trail enthusiasts will find the Topo Athletic Traverse to be a highly versatile, durable trail shoe. The Traverse is designed mainly for multi-day efforts like thru-hiking, FKTs, and multi-day races. It features improved components for faster drying, reducing moisture absorption in the insole, increased durability in the upper, and an aggressive set of lugs with a Vibram Megagrip outsole.

All these elements, combined with Topo’s well-known wide toe box and minimal heel-to-toe drop, create a long-lasting, comfortable trail runner. Those who split their time between trail running and hiking will discover this to be a great all-around shoe and a solid value for the miles it offers. 

However, those seeking maximum cushioning, better breathability, or overall width and volume (not just in the toe box) may want to consider other options. 

What Other Women’s Trail Runners Should You Consider?

If the Topo Athletic Traverse doesn’t meet your needs, consider these similar trail runners with trail-approved traction.

Topo MTN Racer Review: Check out this Editor’s Pick if you’re looking for a trail shoe that offers aggressive traction and excels on more technical terrain with more cushioning.

Saucony Peregrine 15 Review: Check out this Editor’s Pick if you’re looking for a minimal drop trail shoe that offers room for your toes while keeping a more traditional profile and highly breathable mesh.

Brooks Cascadia 18 Review: If you want plenty of toe room, a more traditional drop, and increased durability, these trail runners might be just what you need. They come in two widths.

Bottom Line

The Topo Athletic MTN Racer 4 is our top choice for trail running, and it’s easy to see why. Featuring an aggressive tread and an ultra-sticky Vibram Megagrip outsole, this shoe is built for serious performance on almost any trail. The thick cushioning and breathable upper provide comfort whether you’re racing or logging long training sessions in the mountains. The spacious toe box provides ample space, and the performance midfoot secures your foot, preventing any sloppiness.

Our team tested the MTN Racer 4 on various trails in Pennsylvania, New Hampshire, and across the Pyrenees Mountains. No matter the terrain, the MTN Racer 4 delivered exceptional performance. We loved the durable construction, which protected against sharp rocks, and appreciated the breathability on hot days. The cushioning kept our feet feeling fresh even at the end of really long days.

See our other favorites in our guide to the best trail running shoes for women.

How We Tested

We tested the Topo MTN Racer 4 during training runs and hikes in Pennsylvania and New Hampshire, including several miles on the Appalachian Trail. Our testing concluded with a thru-hike of the Haute Randonee Pyrenees along the Spanish and French border.

Traction

The thing we love most about the Topo MTN Racer 4 is its incredible traction. Thanks to the sticky Vibram Megagrip outsole and the deep lugs, we never lost our footing, even on the notoriously rocky Pyrenees High Route and Appalachian Trail. Whether on dirt trails, muddy slopes, or slabby rock, these shoes gripped well.

The only drawback, if it can be called that, is that if your runs involve more compact surfaces like short stretches of pavement or gravel, the outsole might be overkill and feel a bit too sticky. We reserved these trail runners for our truly technical runs and hikes for that reason.

comfort

The Topo MTN Racer 4 hits that sweet spot between comfort and performance. While there are more slipper-like comfort trail shoes available, they often feel sloppy or don’t perform well on technical terrain. The MTN Racer 4 features Topo’s standard anatomical footbox combined with a more body-hugging midfoot. These design elements kept our feet feeling secure and offered ample space for our toes without excess lateral movement. 

The heel cup also provided a secure, snug fit. However, runners with higher volume or wide feet might find them a bit restrictive. Additionally, the high cushioning protected our feet from rocks, reduced fatigue, and kept us feeling fresh during long days in the mountains.

Weight

Coming in at 17 ounces per pair, the Topo MTN Racer 4 hits the mark. It has a similar weight to many other trail runners we tested, but offers significantly more cushioning than the Saucony Peregrine 14 or Topo Traverse.

This means you don’t have to sacrifice comfort for lightness; your feet won’t get tired from lifting heavy shoes repeatedly during long runs, and you’ll have the added protection of the cushion. It’s a win-win.

Durability

Nike has improved the durability of the Pegasus Trail 5 with several adjustments, including reinforcing the front of the shoe with a robust rubber rand. Additionally, they have integrated segments of a more tightly woven fabric into the single layer mesh upper at key high-wear points. This underscores their commitment to making a more durable trail runner that will perform for miles. 

Throughout the course of testing, we did not notice any obvious signs of wear and tear. However, we have some reservations about whether the Pegasus Trail 5 will hold up to prolonged exposure on high abrasion terrain or punctures from sticks. However, with care, they seem to be made to withstand many miles of light to moderate trail use.

Breathability

While the Topo MTN Racer 4 ranks highly for breathability, there is some trade-off for the added overlays and durability. Despite this, our feet remained cool even on hot weather days, and the shoe dispersed moisture well, lowering the risk of blisters.

Topo also uses their FKT insole, which is closed-cell and non-absorbent. This helped the MTN Racer 4 drain and dry faster after crossing creeks and during long stretches of rainy weather. However, those who regularly recreate or race in very hot, humid, or wet conditions might find that these don’t provide the level of breathability they need.

Responsiveness

With a thick 33×28 mm stack height, the Topo MTN Racer 4 doesn’t look like it would offer the level of responsiveness it does. However, the cushion felt springy and nimble, providing us with great energy return while protecting our feet from rocks, roots, and pounding.

The secure fit of the midfoot helped us feel in control on tight turns and more technical terrain since our feet never slid inside the shoe. While there is plenty of cushion, we still felt connected to the ground, which we prefer, especially on more technical terrain where we need to adapt to a wide variety of surfaces that change with every step. 

Should You Buy the Women’s Topo Athletic MTN Racer 4?

Runners looking for a high cushion, high-performance trail runner that combines aggressive traction with a roomy toe box will find a lot of value in the Topo Athletic MTN Racer 4. Made for rugged, technical trails, this shoe is perfect for those training or racing in the mountains and isn’t as well-suited for gravel or compact dirt. While they offer enhanced durability and drainage, this might slightly reduce breathability, which is a consideration for runners in very hot and humid climates.

We loved the precise fit in the midfoot and heel that kept our feet from slipping, which is often an issue in wider toe box models, although some might find it a bit too restrictive in the midfoot and may want to size up half a size. Their incredible durability, combined with an average price point among trail runners, makes them an excellent value in terms of cost per mile. Overall, these shoes are a great choice for long, tough days in the mountains. 

What Other Women’s Trail Runners Should You Consider?

If the Topo Athletic MTN Racer 4 isn’t the shoe for you, check out these similar trail runners that combine performance cushioning with trail-approved traction.

Topo Traverse Review: Check out this Editor’s Pick if you want a highly responsive trail shoe with aggressive traction that performs well on technical terrain, offering less cushion and more ground feel.

Saucony Peregrine 15 Review: Check out this Editor’s Pick if you’re seeking a minimal drop trail shoe that provides room for your toes, maintains a traditional profile, and features highly breathable mesh.

New Balance Fresh Foam Hierro x v9 Review: Looking for a Vibram grip with maximum cushioning and greater versatility? These shoes will easily take you from dry trails to wet pavement.

Bottom Line

We found the Katabatic Flex 22 to be impressively versatile, warm, and comfortable. It offers several temperature options, making the ordering experience more straightforward compared to many other quilts we tested. 

Katabatic adds extra value with a reliable pad attachment system, a storage bag, and a stuff sack. The most impressive feature is its highly water-resistant down fill. Thanks to the ExpeDRY treated down, the Flex maintains its loft even in damp conditions and dries faster, making it a strong choice for backpackers in wetter climates.

However, the Flex has some drawbacks compared to similar models, mainly its higher price, weight, and bulk. Also, the Flex’s horizontal continuous baffles can make it difficult to keep the down fill in place if you toss and turn. That said, hikers who tend to stay still while sleeping probably won’t find this to be a big problem.

To see all the backpacking quilts we tested, see our best backpacking quilts gear guide.

How We Tested

Our gear analysts tested the Katabatic Flex 22 in late spring during overnight trips in the Cascade foothills and the coastal Pacific Northwest.

Warmth

As is common in the industry, we found the Katabatic Flex 22’s warmth rating to be rather generous. Most small manufacturers do not have their products EN tested (check out our best sleeping bags and best backpacking quilts gear guides for more info). 

We used this quilt on spring trips where the temperatures were typically in the 40s Fahrenheit and felt comfortable. One night, the temperature dipped into the upper 30s, and we noticed it was harder to stay warm. Those expecting cooler temperatures or who sleep cold will want to choose the 15-degree version. 

Since it features continuous horizontal baffles, on cold nights, you can move the down to the center of the quilt, ensuring it’s where you need it most: on top of your body. On warmer nights, you can shift the down to the sides to prevent overheating. This is a bit of a pro move, but it can be helpful if you’re aware of it.

However, the hyperDry down fill helped us stay warmer on cold, wet nights in the Pacific Northwest. Those who hike primarily in wet climates, or who routinely have condensation issues will find this to be a boon that will help them stay warmer than untreated down.

Comfort

The Katabatic Flex 22 is one of the most comfortable quilts we tested. Its spacious design and fluffy loft made it a cozy nest to look forward to at the end of the day. The Flex 22 offers three length options and two width options. The length choices are designed for hikers up to 5’6”, 6’, or 6’6”. Width options are available in both the 6’ and 6’6” lengths.

If you’re in doubt, we recommend choosing a longer and wider size for full coverage during chilly nights. This is especially helpful if you need to wear extra clothing like a bulky puffy coat or want to pull the quilt over your head.

The closure cords keep the quilt securely closed enough to eliminate gaps when rolling around in our sleep. However, the narrow round cords are slightly uncomfortable if used without inserting a pad; otherwise, we had no significant complaints about the overall comfort and performance of this quilt.

Weight & Packability

The Flex is heavier and bulkier than other quilts in this range. While we value the roominess and loft, it can be difficult to fit into a standard ultralight backpack. This might not be a dealbreaker for those with a more traditional pack, but if space is limited in your setup, another option may be better.

Depending on the size you select, the Flex 22 weighs between 21-28 oz, which is very light for a sleeping bag or quilt. This is a big win for us and an important factor to consider for any backpacking trip.

Features

The Flex 22 quilt can be opened completely like a comforter on warmer nights or you can zip and close the footbox completely when temperatures drop. You can also use the included pad attachment straps to hold the quilt securely over your body on cold nights. We love this design and versatility.

The footbox has a zipper that runs about 1/3 the length of the quilt and helps create an enclosed place for your feet on chilly nights. To fully enclose the footbox: zip up the zipper, snap the footbox enclosure, and pull the drawstring.

The Katabatic Flex 22 has one of the more secure quilt pad attachment systems we’ve tested. It comes with two lightweight yellow cords that you tie around your sleeping pad and attach to the quilt. Additionally, it comes with two stretchy elastic straps with clips that can pass through loops on the quilt to keep the bottom opening from widening.

Should You Buy The Katabatic Flex 22?

We think the Katabatic Flex 22 quilt is an excellent option for backpackers seeking a versatile three-season quilt. Those looking for a lay flat quilt who sleep warm (or won’t be out in below freezing temperatures) will be pleased with this option. 

However, it is not the lightest or cheapest backpacking quilt on the market and won’t be the best fit for everyone.

What Other Backpacking Quilts Should You Consider?

If the Katabatic Flex 22 isn’t for you, there are many other options in our best backpacking quilts gear guide.

Western Mountaineering AstraLite Quilt Review:  Our Editor’s pick for the Best Overall Backpacking Quilt has the best warmth-to-weight ratio of any quilt we tested, weighing in at a mere 16 ounces.

Hyperlite Mountain Gear 20-Degree Quilt Review: This Editor’s Pick for Warmest Ultralight Backpacking quilt offers exceptional warmth without the added weight and bulk. It achieves this with 1000 fill power down.

Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 Review:  Our top pick for versatile sleeping bag hybrid offers a slightly roomier cut that will accommodate more room to move without making it hard to heat. Great for those looking for an adjustable foot box.

Bottom Line

If you’re looking for a warm quilt that won’t cost too much, the Hammock Gear Burrow 20 is a good option. This quilt is one of the warmest and most durable choices out there, making its affordability especially appealing.

The Burrow is customizable without becoming too complicated. This makes it easy to find the perfect sleep system, which can help first-time quilt buyers who might feel overwhelmed by options from other companies. Hammock Gear lets you choose essential elements like length, width, and footbox style, while skipping more detailed choices such as stitching color. For maximum warmth, go with a sewn footbox, and think about adding a little extra down overfill to the areas you find most important.

If you’re willing to spend a little more to lower your base weight, the Burrow UL is worth considering. It provides the same simple customization options but is a full six ounces lighter and much easier to pack.

You can see more options in our best backpacking quilts gear guide.

How We Tested

Gear Analyst Heather Anderson took the Burrow on an early-season coastal trek in Washington State. She also took it on an overnight trip along the Pacific Northwest Trail. Overnight low temperatures ranged from the upper 30s to low 40s Fahrenheit.

Warmth

The Burrow 20 was warm for its weight and performed well compared to similarly rated quilts. While our testers were comfortable into the upper 30s, the 20-degree rating feels generous. Choosing the 20-denier nylon taffeta fabric for the outer and inner faces makes for a warmer bag overall. Additionally, this fabric is less expensive and more durable, making it a good choice overall if weight savings aren’t your primary concern. 

We appreciated the cinchable draft collar and footbox during the coldest nights, and we also used the attachment clips to block drafts. This quilt is relatively narrow, which helps with heating. We would prefer slightly higher clips at the top to keep the quilt more secure around our shoulders.

Comfort

Our average-height testers liked the slim cut of the Hammock Gear Burrow, which made it cozy and easy to heat. However, taller users might want to get the longer version to have more material to tuck around their shoulders, especially if you’ll mainly be using it in colder temperatures. The loft of this quilt made it feel fluffier and cozier than other options in its class.

Overall, we found this to be a very comfortable quilt for various conditions, largely thanks to its versatile features. 

We feel that the thicker fabric isn’t as comfortable on bare skin as the lower-denier ripstop used on most other quilts. However, that certainly isn’t a deal breaker if you’re wearing sleep clothes.

Weight & Packability

The Hammock Gear Burrow 20 is a basic model quilt, but it still provides several customization options. You can choose your size, fill power, and fabric weight or color. Additionally, you can select the type of footbox, draft collars, and overfill.

Our testers found the zip footbox to be more versatile than the sewn one, especially on warmer nights when we wanted to vent the quilt more. On colder nights, with the footbox fully cinched and zipped, we didn’t experience any drafts.

Our testers overlooked the inclusion of a draft collar on the model we tested, which would have helped keep our shoulders warmer. The clips on the bottom of the quilt were easy to use for securing it in place, and our active sleepers were impressed by the lack of drafts.

Features

The Hammock Gear Burrow 20 is a basic model quilt, but it still provides several customization options. You can choose your size, fill power, and fabric weight or color. Additionally, you can select the type of footbox, draft collars, and overfill.

Our testers found the zip footbox to be more versatile than the sewn one, especially on warmer nights when we wanted to vent the quilt more. On colder nights, with the footbox fully cinched and zipped, we didn’t experience any drafts.

Our testers overlooked the inclusion of a draft collar on the model we tested, which would have helped keep our shoulders warmer. The clips on the bottom of the quilt were easy to use for securing it in place, and our active sleepers were impressed by the lack of drafts.

Should You Buy The Hammock Gear Burrow 20?

Backpackers wanting to see if a quilt suits their needs will find the Hammock Gear Burrow 20 to be a great choice. It is the most affordable model we tested, but you don’t have to give up warmth or features to keep the price down. Some customizations are available, but not so many that first-timers will get overwhelmed.

Seasoned quilt users will also find this to be a great value. In addition to the budget-friendly price, customers can choose important options such as fill power, size, foot box style, and draft collar.

The Burrow was also one of the most durable quilts we tested, which makes it even more appealing for those who want to invest in a sleep system that will last a long time. However, backpackers who prioritize weight and packability may want to look elsewhere.

What Other Backpacking Quilts Should You Consider?

 If the Hammock Gear Burrow 20 isn’t for you, head to our main gear guide to see all of our top picks for the best best backpacking quilts.

Western Mountaineering AstraLite Quilt Review:  Our Editor’s pick for the Best Overall Backpacking Quilt has the best warmth-to-weight ratio of any quilt we tested and weighs only 16 ounces.

Hyperlite Mountain Gear 20-Degree Quilt Review: Our Editor’s pick for the Warmest Ultralight Backpacking Quilt keeps you warm without the weight and bulk thanks to ultralight fabrics and 1000 fill power down.

Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 Review: Our top pick for a versatile sleeping bag hybrid will keep you warmer than the similarly rated Burrow. The slightly roomier cut provides more room to move without making it hard to stay warm.

Bottom Line

The UGQ Bandit 20 offers a wide range of customization options. UCQ has many color choices. If you’re ordering for the first time, it might feel a bit overwhelming, but the Features tab on the ordering page is full of helpful information to guide your decisions. If you’re willing to spend a little extra, consider adding the neckline draft collar for extra warmth.

The baffle design effectively keeps the down securely in place, giving the Bandit a fluffier feel compared to some other quilts. While it may not be the most compact option for packing, the bulk is manageable. For backpackers looking to save space or who tend to sleep colder, the 950-fill-power down upgrade is worth considering. I am running a few minutes late; my previous meeting is running over.

If you’re a backpacker looking for the comfort of a custom quilt, the Bandit provides that while keeping your pack lightweight.

Check out best backpacking quilts gear guide for more backpacking quilt options.

How We Tested

Gear analyst Heather Anderson took the Bandit on weekend backpacking trips throughout the coastal Pacific Northwest.

Warmth

The UGQ Bandit was the least warm of the similarly rated quilts we tested. Our testers took it on spring trips in the Coastal Cascades where overnight lows were in the low 40s Fahrenheit. We found the quilt comfortable at that temperature, but as the mercury dipped into the 30s one night, we struggled to stay warm. 

Adding a neckline draft collar and opting for overfill will help significantly, especially if you’re a cold sleeper. Another option is to get the overstuffed footbox if cold feet tend to be a problem for you. Overall, this bag would be good for late spring, summer, and early autumn, or for those who anticipate steady overnight lows well above freezing.

Comfort

We loved the fluffy comfort of the UGC Bandit 20. Not only was it a great quilt for sleeping, we also enjoyed snuggling in it during our pre-sleep camp activities. This quilt is loftier than many others we tested, partly because of the baffle design. It made it especially inviting after a long, wet day of hiking in the Pacific Northwest rainforest. 

The fabric felt soft against the skin without feeling sticky like some competitive models. We also found that it hit the ideal size for most people. It was roomy enough not to feel tight, even for our active sleepers, but it wasn’t so big that we had trouble heating the space.

Weight & Packability

The UGQ Bandit 20 is right in the middle, weightwise, of the quilt models we tested. At its temperature rating and price point, it is slightly heavier and bulkier than similar models. Part of this can be offset by choosing a higher fill power (available in 950 as well as 850) and a full taper shape. However, opting for the tapered design reduces some of its versatility. 

While it easily fits into a fairly standard ultralight backpack, it occupies a good amount of space, which could be a concern for some, especially those using minimal volume packs. Despite these considerations, the Bandit remains a solid choice for anyone looking for a lightweight quilt that delivers good performance.

Features

Honestly, the customization options for the UGQ Bandit 20 can be overwhelming, especially for first-time quilt shoppers. However, for those who know exactly what they want, it’s possible to fine-tune it to your specific specs. We appreciated that the Bandit 20 can be laid completely flat on warmer nights or cinched up on colder ones. This also made it easier to use as a blanket when in camp before bed. Because it doesn’t have a sewn footbox, our testers were able to snuggle in it during chilly nights while eating. 

However, we found the pad straps and closures to be a bit odd in their design. Simple clips or elastics would be better than the notched tabs with thin cord. We loved the ability to partially unzip the bottom to form a footbox that could then be fully cinched shut. Our toes stayed warm with this system.

Should You Buy The UGQ Bandit 20?

If you’re looking for a highly customizable quilt for summer backpacking, the UGQ Bandit 20 might be the right choice. Those who sleep cold or plan to be out in temperatures close to the rating may want to choose a different quilt or go for overstuff, as we found the rating to be somewhat too generous.

With two fill options, available overfill, multiple footbox styles, various lengths and sizes, plus numerous color choices, this is one of the most customizable quilts we tested. While this variety might be overwhelming for some, experienced quilt users who know exactly what they want in their ideal sleep system will appreciate the options.

Unfortunately, all this customization comes at a cost; the Bandit sits right in the middle of our options. Those on a budget may want to consider other choices.

What Other Backpacking Quilts Should You Consider?

If the UGQ Bandit 20 isn’t for you, there are many other options in our gear guide to best backpacking quilts.

Western Mountaineering AstraLite Quilt Review: Our Editor’s pick for the Best Overall Backpacking Quilt offers the best warmth-to-weight ratio of any quilt we tested and weighs just 16 ounces.

Hyperlite Mountain Gear 20-Degree Quilt Review: Our Editor’s pick for the Warmest Ultralight Backpacking Quilt keeps you warm without the weight and bulk thanks to ultralight fabrics and 1000 fill power down.

Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 Review: Our top choice for a versatile sleeping bag hybrid features a slightly roomier design that provides more space to move without sacrificing warmth. Those seeking an adjustable foot box will find it here.

Bottom Line

The Loco Libre Ghost Pepper 20 is among the warmer quilts we tested. While we don’t often find quilts to be truly warm enough for three-season use, this one is when paired with a high R-value pad. Although we didn’t find it comfortable down to its 20-degree rating, it performed well for cold sleepers into the 30s.

Its unique chevron baffles effectively keep down in place, enhancing warmth where you need it most. Our testers appreciated the adjustability of the pad straps as well as the drawstrings and snaps at the collar and footbox to make it even more enclosed when the mercury dropped.

Loco Libre offers a wide range of customization, including fill, warmth ratings, colors, and accessories. The level of available customization can be overwhelming for first-time users, however, it does make it possible to truly tailor your quilt to your preferences.

To see more of our favorites, check out the best backpacking quilts gear guide.

How We Tested

Our testers used this bag on a spring trip to South Dakota’s Badlands and for an overnight stay on Michigan’s North Country Trail. Temperatures ranged from the upper 30s to low 40s Fahrenheit during both trips.

Warmth

The Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 was warmer than many of the similarly rated quilts we tested; however, our colder sleepers still found the rating to be generous. During our trip to the Badlands in South Dakota in early May, overnight lows dipped into the upper 30s. We stayed warm enough with a high R-Value pad, but we had the footbox and neck fully cinched and used pad straps to keep warm.

We suspect that temperatures at or below freezing would be the maximum comfortable range. Those seeking a three-season quilt will find this option suitable as long as overnight lows below freezing are not frequent. If they are, backpackers may want to consider additional customization options such as adding a neck draft collar, the “Hot Box” footbox, extra down, or selecting a lower temperature rating.

Comfort

Overall, the Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 was a very comfortable quilt. We appreciated its versatility—being able to lay it flat as a comforter on warm nights and cinch it down on colder ones.

Our testers found the standard length and width to hit the perfect balance for volume. There was enough space to move around without making it difficult to stay warm. We also liked using it as a blanket while relaxing around camp in the morning and evening, which helped reduce the number of “warm for camp” layers we needed to pack on our spring trips.

Weight & Packability

This quilt provides an excellent warmth-to-weight ratio mainly due to the 850 fill power down. In terms of weight, the Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 falls right in the middle of similarly rated quilts, but its warmth is significantly higher, making it stand out in its category. We found that although this bag was quite lofty, we could pack it down into a fairly small stuff sack.

Our testers had no trouble packing it into an ultralight pack, whether using a stuff sack or the loose packing method. Its versatility as a wrap or blanket while sitting around camp enhances the weight and space savings. Our testers were able to skip the down puffy and pants they usually bring for camp, as they could effectively wrap up in this quilt without being confined to one position like they would be with a sewn footbox or a standard mummy bag.

Features

Loco Libre offers a wide range of customization options for their products. The Operator series features a more streamlined set of choices, making it an excellent starting point for both first-time quilt users and experienced ones.

We tested the basic version of the Ghost Pepper 20 in the Operator series during our trips to South Dakota and Michigan in late spring. While our testers were happy with the performance, we would add the neck collar if we used it again for extra warmth.

We also found the pad straps to be somewhat fiddly, with clips that are hard to attach and an additional toggle for tightening. We prefer simple elastic lay-flat straps and slip attachments, but this is a minor issue.

Should You Buy The Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20?

The Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 provides great value for backpackers seeking a warm-for-its-weight quilt that performs well in various conditions. Those expecting to encounter freezing or below temperatures should consider a more insulated or higher-warmth model. 

With numerous customizations available, the Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 can be adjusted to fit most needs at a reasonable price. Our testers also appreciated the craftsmanship made in the USA, though the long lead time from order to delivery (about a month in our experience) requires some planning ahead.

Those needing a last-minute option might want to explore other companies that offer stock models. Overall, we believe the versatility of this quilt makes it a reliable choice for a broad range of backpackers.

What Other Backpacking Quilts Should You Consider?

If the Loco Libre Operator Series Ghost Pepper 20 isn’t for you, head to our gear guide to best backpacking quilts to see many more options.

Western Mountaineering AstraLite Quilt Review: Our Editor’s pick for the Best Overall Backpacking Quilt offers the best warmth-to-weight ratio of any quilt we tested and weighs only 16 ounces.

Hyperlite Mountain Gear 20-Degree Quilt Review: Our Editor’s pick for the Warmest Ultralight Backpacking Quilt keeps you warm without the weight and bulk thanks to ultralight fabrics and 1000 fill power down.

Enlightened Equipment Revelation 20 Review: This quilt is one of our team favorites. It features a great mix of characteristics that make it a highly versatile choice that won’t cost a lot. Besides being affordable, it is quite warm for its weight and has a very packable design.

Bottom Line

Quilts built for two are an excellent way for couples to slash base weight. The ZPacks 20F Twin Quilt is the top choice among the doubles we tested. With 900 fill power down and a sewn-in footbox, it weighs much less than two separate bags while providing excellent warmth for the weight. 

In addition to saving weight, this quilt can also provide significant monetary savings, as it costs less than two regular quilts of a similar rating. If you and your partner can sleep cooperatively, this may be an excellent value. Our only caveats are the absence of pad straps to help keep it in place, which can be an issue with two people tossing and turning, and the lack of a neck baffle to help with drafts. However, neither of these issues were deal breakers for our testers on late spring nights in the mid-Atlantic region of the Appalachian Trail.

Find all of our favorites in the best backpacking quilts gear guide.

How We Tested

Gear Analyst Heather Anderson tested the ZPacks 20F Twin on a section hike of the Appalachian Trail in the mid-Atlantic Region in late May. Overnight temperatures ranged from the mid to upper 40s Fahrenheit.

Warmth

While the ZPacks 20F Twin Quilt weighs under 28 ounces, it delivers impressive warmth. Although we didn’t test it to the bottom edge of its range on our AT section hike, we believe it would keep us fairly warm. One of the biggest advantages of a double quilt is that you can share body heat to stay warmer. Our testers found this to be true with the Twin.

We liked the sewn-in footbox that wasn’t restrictive. The roominess, which was sufficient without being excessive, also helped it stay warmer than expected. However, we missed the neck baffle found in the Enlightened Equipment Accomplice. We also think pad straps would be helpful on colder nights to prevent cold spots. We recommend using straps to keep your pads together and avoid gaps that can let in cold.

Comfort

The ZPacks Twin was more comfortable than other double quilts we tested. We found it to be roomy enough for two without being so spacious that it was hard to stay warm, which was one problem we had with the Enlightened Equipment Accomplice. However, taller hikers or those wanting a bit more space might prefer the Accomplice.

The sewn-in footbox was large enough that sharing it wasn’t an issue. The only thing that could have made this quilt more comfortable would have been a little more length or a neck baffle for better snuggling on cold nights.

Weight & Packability

At just under 28 ounces, the ZPacks Twin weighs considerably less than two separate sleeping bags or quilts. This weight reduction is often the main reason for choosing a double quilt system. Additionally, the cost is less than half of two, adding further value.

The main drawback of using a double quilt is that it occupies more space in a pack compared to a single quilt. Therefore, couples choosing this option will likely need to balance the volume by rearranging other gear. However, we found the Twin to take up considerably less room than other double quilts like the Accomplice, making it much more practical for backpacking.

Features

The Zpacks 20F Twin has few features compared to most other quilts. It has no baffles, no pad straps, and no adjustable cinches on the neck or footbox. Our testers found this simplicity refreshing.

However, those who tend to roll around a lot at night or are less cooperative sleepers with their partners will miss the straps that help keep the quilt in place. In colder temperatures, a neck baffle or cinch would be welcome for extra warmth. In warmer weather, our testers would prefer some way to vent the foot box. 

Should You Buy The ZPacks 20F Twin Quilt?

Couples looking for a three-season quilt that will not only reduce their base weight but also save money will find the ZPacks 20F Twin Quilt to be an excellent value. Those considering switching to a double quilt should test it before embarking on a multi-night trip to ensure it suits them.

Sharing a quilt in the backcountry can be tricky and isn’t suitable for everyone. The Twin may present a steeper learning curve than other doubles because it lacks pad straps and baffles that help prevent cold spots from tossing and turning. However, for those who find the double system works well, the Twin Quilt offers simplicity, warmth, and functionality.

What Other Backpacking Quilts Should You Consider?

If the ZPacks 20F Twin Quilt isn’t for you, there are many other options in our gear guide to best backpacking quilts.

Enlightened Equipment Accomplice 20: Couples seeking a more versatile and customizable double quilt will find this option appealing. With a wider cut and padded straps, this quilt provides a more secure fit and offers fuller coverage.

Western Mountaineering AstraLight Review: If you’re looking for a single-person quilt, our overall best backpacking quilt keeps you warm without the weight and bulk. It also packs down, making it easy to accommodate in smaller ultralight packs. Couples can utilize two of these without a significant weight penalty over the Twin.

Hyperlite Mountain Gear 20-Degree Quilt Review: If you’re looking for a single quilt that performs well in colder conditions and has simple, effective pad straps, this Editor’s Pick is an excellent option. Its stock model production means it’s available without a long lead time. Additionally, it’s simple to use the pad straps to make set-up in camp a breeze.