Bottom Line

A top choice for hikers and paddlers, the Chaco Z/1 Classics firmly rank among our best hiking sandals. Featuring a thick, durable midsole, these favored sandals shield your feet from rugged trail conditions while providing toe mobility and breathability. Our tester appreciates the one-loop strap adjustment system, offering a tailored and snug fit for all foot shapes. 

Initially, the Z/1 Classics may appear pricey, yet we find them incredibly durable, making them a worthwhile investment. Should they break or become unusable after considerable use, Chaco will repair them for a small fee via their ReChaco program.

How We Tested

We waltzed around Southern California for weeks with the Chaco Z/1 Classics on our feet. We took them on numerous hikes in the Los Padres National Forest and wore them all over San Luis Obispo, Santa Barbara, and Ventura, California. These shoes faced everything from steep sandstone slopes to waterfront boardwalks.

Comfort

Ironically, our lead sandal tester had a pair of Chaco Z/1 Classics about six years ago and really hated them: she seriously despised them. She wore them on an 8-mile hike with several water crossings and a lot of river rock-hopping one summer, and ended up with so many blisters that she vowed never to wear a pair of Chacos again. Well, here she is, more than half a decade later, testing the Chaco Z/1 Classics for this review. Life, you know? 

Anyway, we’re gleeful to report that her second experience with these sandals was not nearly as bad. In fact, she can’t say she hates these sandals anymore. (Losing a key part of her personality here, she says, but we digress.) Our tester still finds some aspects of the Z/1 Classics uncomfortable—for instance, the arch support is a bit too aggressive for her; she feels like her feet are being forced upward—but for the most part, she can manage a day of outdoor activities in these shoes. After several moderate hikes and many days at camp, our tester’s feet haven’t developed any hot spots or blisters, and we call that a win. 

The straps don’t dig into her medium-width feet, and the slightly contoured heel cup provides a helpful yet unobtrusive level of support. The arch support, as previously noted, isn’t ideal for our tester’s foot anatomy but is a plus for hikers seeking more supportive sandals. The midsole is quite dense, nearly bordering on too hard, but that’s a beneficial feature if you’re in search of a sandal that offers substantial energy return (it helps you feel bouncier on your feet).

Stability

These are stable! They’re quite rigid compared to many other hiking sandals we’ve tried, which may be a downside for some people but a benefit for others. Specifically, those who desire freedom for their toes while still needing a secure fit around the heel and ankle will appreciate the Chaco Z/1 Classics. The contour around the heel significantly enhances foot security within the sandal. 

Those who want a more flexible sandal may not jive with the polyurethane midsole on these. Its rigidity provides stability but limits natural foot flexion and extension. The midsole feels almost like that of a hiking boot, preventing you from feeling rocks or other features beneath your feet. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it’s worth considering if you enjoy feeling more connected to the ground or plan to wear your sandals in situations that require a lot of foot flexibility.

Traction

With a 3-millimeter lug depth, the Z/1 Classics are suitable for mild to moderate terrain. After taking them on several short (two- to three-mile) hikes and wearing them in various outdoor environments, including national forest primitive campsites, forest roads, and urban settings, we can vouch for these as an all-around type of sandal. 

Our tester says she personally wouldn’t take them on strenuous hikes with very slippery surfaces, such as scree fields or slickrock (her butt did meet the ground when attempting to hike down a primarily sandstone trail, and she ended up doing more scree skiing than hiking), but they are more than capable of safely traversing Class I and Class II trails. They’re also nice for wearing around town on warm days.

Durability

During testing, we haven’t observed any early signs of wear and tear. So far, the polyester webbing straps remain perfectly intact, as does the textured pattern on the footbed. Chaco Z/1 Classics feature Vibram insoles, known for their longevity, so we don’t anticipate any issues with that, either. 

As always, plastic components (the buckle, in this case) are a concern, but Chaco offers a lifetime repair program and will fix them for $10 per buckle. You can also have your outsole re-soled and your straps repaired, unstuck, or lengthened/shortened for much less than the cost of buying a new pair. Major hoorah to Chaco for this!

Weight & Packability

The Chaco Z/1 Classics are on the heavier side of the sandal spectrum, weighing approximately 1.5 pounds per pair. This weight results from the chunky, dense polyurethane midsole, which gives them a stack height of over an inch at the thickest point. 

Though they are heavy enough to deter many backpackers from choosing them as camp shoes, we believe they work well for day hikes that involve minor water crossings, or for shorter backpacking trips where weight is less of a concern.

Although they are chunky, we prefer to pack these inside the backpack instead of attaching them to the outside. Due to their bulkiness, they tend to sway around when hooked to the exterior, which can quickly become bothersome.

Ease of Use

The heel strap on the Z/1 Classics is fixed, but the ankle, midfoot, and forefoot straps all adjust. These three straps function as a single strap; they do not adjust independently. This means it can take some time to find the right fit, but once you do, you’re set for the lifespan of the sandals (unless the straps stretch out from wear). After the initial adjustment, you’ll only need to loosen and tighten the ankle strap at the buckle, which is very easy to do.

Should You Buy the Women’s Chaco Z/1 Classic?

The Chaco Z/1 Classics are a fantastic all-around choice. While we don’t recommend them for particularly strenuous or steep hikes, we believe they are suitable for easy to moderate hikes, and possibly some challenging ones, depending on the terrain features.

They also make great everyday sandals, making them a good fit for anyone looking for an “everything” sandal. Although they might seem pricey at first, you’ll truly get your money’s worth out of the Z/1 Classics due to their versatility. 

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

The following are some of our favorite hiking sandals and are worthy alternatives to the Z/1 Classics.

Teva Hurricane XLT2 Review: We love the chunky midsole on the Hurricane XLT2s, along with the three independently adjustable straps. These make a great choice for anyone seeking extra stability, thanks to the wide, contoured footbed and extended heel counter. 

Teva Original Universal Review: While not as sturdy as the Hurricane XLT2s, the Teva Original Universals are a personal favorite of our lead sandal tester. Similar to the Z/1 Classics, these sandals are perfect for all-day, everyday wear and can handle moderate trails and water activities.

Ecco Yucatan Review: We recommend the Yucatans for hikers with narrow feet who seek support and stability. The three Velcro straps ensure a secure fit, while the sidebar adds stability to the outside of the foot. Additionally, we appreciate how the straps feel super soft against our skin.

Bottom Line

The Astral Webber hiking sandals are ideal for light hikes on flat terrain, casual town strolls, beach outings, and water sports. In our tests, we discovered that the traction is insufficient for hiking on moderate to steep slopes, particularly when those slopes are slick with sediment. Additionally, hikers may struggle with stability in the Webbers because the forefoot straps often loosen on their own, coupled with a fixed heel strap. 

While we consider them somewhat expensive for the performance they deliver, there are positives: Our tester found wearing the Webbers enjoyable while exploring the city, appreciating their stylish yet functional design. They’re perfect for running errands or enjoying river outings, and would also serve well as camp shoes. Their slim design allows for easy storage in various pack compartments, and we believe hikers will value the comfort and freedom for their feet after a long day in boots. Check out other options in our hiking sandal gear guide.

How We Tested

Over several weeks, our tester wore the Astral Webbers on various short to medium hikes in Southern California, during days at the beach, and while running errands around town. In the course of testing them, she assessed aspects of comfort, stability, durability, traction, ease of use, and packability.

Comfort

The first aspect that stood out to us about these sandals was the texture on the footbed. While we understand it’s likely there for grip, it feels quite sharp. This became very distracting after a while; although not painful, it irritated our tester during hiking in these sandals. However, we appreciate the contour of the footbed; it aligns well with the foot shape of our tester (medium-width midfoot, neutral-to-slightly wide forefoot). 

While these fit our feet well in terms of width, they may be too loose for hikers with narrow feet, particularly those with a narrow heel. There is no heel adjustment, and the heel strap felt somewhat loose on our tester; therefore, these may feel more like flip-flops for some users. 

On a positive note, we adore the material of the heel strap on the Astral Webbers: It’s soft and slightly padded on the interior, so blisters shouldn’t be a problem. The forefoot straps are made of woven nylon: they’re not as soft, but supple enough not to dig into the skin. 

Our biggest comfort-related complaint with the Webbers is the size of the buckles. They’re large enough to be very noticeable while hiking, and if you tighten the straps for an ultra-secure fit, they dig into the top of the foot. Consequently, our tester ended up hiking with the straps a bit looser than she would have preferred, resulting in her feet shifting around in the (pokey) footbeds.

Stability

The Astral Webbers feature a 16-millimeter stack height and a 0-millimeter heel-to-toe drop. This, along with the subtle contour of the footbed, creates a nice blend of support and ground feel. The midsole is made from closed-cell EVA foam, which is dense and offers a supportive, yet not overly plush, experience. 

The design leaves much to be desired regarding ankle stability, as the midfoot strap sits quite far from the front of the ankle, and the heel strap sits low—well below the ankle bone, at least on our lead tester. When hiking, we also found that the straps tend to loosen on their own. It’s not significant, but it is certainly noticeable and requires us to stop and adjust the straps many times throughout a given jaunt.

Traction

Given our lackluster experience with comfort and stability, we hoped the traction on the Astral Webbers would pleasantly surprise us. Unfortunately, they performed poorly in this category as well.

On a 6-mile hike in dry, dry Southern California, our tester busted her butt three times on the trail’s silty terrain. To be fair, the trail was typical of the region, featuring a fine (quarter- to half-inch) layer of fine sediment over rock—meaning it is super slippery by nature. 

Still, we feel that the tester shouldn’t be going heels-up on grades below 15%. After finishing the hike, we removed the sandals to inspect the outsole and confirm our beliefs: Yes, the outsole lugs are rather shallow, and the lug pattern features broad, flat squares. There’s nothing there that can really dig into the earth you’re walking on. 

The Astral Webbers performed better on other surfaces, including gravel at moderate angles. We also wore them on the beach and enjoyed them for that purpose. Notably, Astral specifies on the product page that these are intended for water activities and casual use, so we feel we shouldn’t be too hard on them here.

Durability

These seem more or less average to us in terms of durability. The dense, closed-cell EVA foam midsole should prove resistant to compression, and the tightly woven nylon straps should hold up to varied trail conditions over an extended period. However, due to the lug pattern and depth, we feel the outsole may wear down quicker than other, more robust outsoles. 

We wore the Astral Webbers while hiking through relatively thick Southern California brush (yes, we were scared of encountering rattlesnakes!), and they got snagged a couple of times on the typical spiky flora. 

Despite a few encounters with thorns, we have not noticed any abrasions or tears on the straps. We lack confidence in the plastic buckles (just because plastic parts and the outdoors don’t tend to go so well together), but we believe most people will wear down the tread to the point of needing new sandals before the buckles break.

Weight & Packability

What the Webbers lack in traction and stability, they compensate for with weight and packability. The 16-millimeter stack height and zero-drop sole ensure these shoes are highly packable and can fit into small spaces, especially if you separate them into different packing compartments. 

These would make excellent camp shoes. They’re not the lightest, but they’re light enough for anyone who isn’t a dedicated ultra-lighter. At 14.6 ounces, most hikers will barely notice they’re there, but they’re certifiably too much for an ultralight enthusiast.

Ease of Use

We found the Webbers easy to put on and take off. The buckle mechanism is straightforward to use and adjust, but the straps can become loose over time while hiking. It’s a quick fix—just pull them tight again—but it can become annoying after a while.

Should You Buy the Astral Webber Hiking Sandals?

For the price, we believe there are better-performing hiking sandals available (and options that can perform as well as the Astral Webbers for a lower cost). That said, if you really like the style of these sandals, they’re probably worth it: We haven’t tested any other hiking sandals with quite the same aesthetic.

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

If you’re not convinced that the Astral Webbers are the best hiking sandals for you, try some of these similar options.

Teva Original Universal Review: Half the price yet just as functional, the Teva Original Universals are an excellent budget-friendly choice for hikers seeking a stylish and versatile sandal for casual wear. Their plusher midsole and adjustable heel strap provide a more comfortable fit, our tester states. 

Luna Mono Winged Review: A semi-minimalist pick, the Luna Mono Winged hiking sandals feature a zero-millimeter heel-to-toe drop with a 15-millimeter stack height, making them feel much sturdier than a typical barefoot-inspired sandal. They are a good choice if you want traction and stability while prioritizing foot freedom.

Ecco Yucatan Review: The Yucatans are much more robust than the Astral Webbers (and the two picks above). They aren’t even close to a minimalist sandal, so if zero-drop is a must, you should pass on these. However, if you’re looking for more stability and greater traction without a toe thong, the Yucatans are definitely worth checking out. 

Bottom Line

The KEEN Rose hiking sandals primarily cater to hikers with narrow feet who struggle to find sandals that fit snugly and also desire toe protection. Their narrow footbed and single adjustment point create a secure fit, while the midsole is plush enough to support all-day wear. However, for anyone with neutral or wide feet, the KEEN Roses are likely to feel restrictive and uncomfortable. 

With a substantial heel-to-toe drop and padded straps, these sandals excel in shock absorption and heel comfort, making them an excellent choice for mild trails and urban walks. Their bulky construction and average traction indicate that these sandals aren’t suited for technical hikes or as a lightweight secondary option. We believe that at 19 ounces per pair, they represent a great option for low-key adventures. Check out other options in our hiking sandal gear guide.

How We Tested

We wore the KEEN Rose sandals across varying terrain, covering several miles in a national forest. While testing them, we considered factors that influenced comfort, stability, traction, durability, ease of use, and weight and packability to evaluate them according to our testing methodology.

Comfort

The KEEN Rose sandals are 100% suited for narrow feet. We tried wearing these with socks because we wanted to do some jogging or downhill running in them, as we did with other sneaker-like sandals. However, we couldn’t even wedge our feet into the sandals with socks on, and the socks weren’t unusually thick; they were light-cushion running socks. So, we ditched the socks and went without them, and even then, we were barely able to squeeze our neutral-width feet in. 

This really shows how narrow they are. We’re not calling this out as a bad thing; it’s actually a great thing for people who have slender feet and struggle to find hiking sandals that fit snugly. 

Because these were so snug on our lead tester, she only managed to hike three miles in them, unable to go further without facing serious discomfort. Because of the tightness, they rubbed the area just below the big toe on both of her feet. She imagines it would develop some intense calluses if she wore them for many miles.

Like many of KEEN’s other sandals, these feature a substantial heel-to-toe drop that can enhance comfort for individuals with limited ankle mobility, especially when hiking on steep uphill trails. Conversely, someone accustomed to barefoot, zero-drop shoes may feel as if they are lugging around 1800s-era clogs. The midsole, made of dense foam, is sturdy yet softer than comparable sandals, including the KEEN Newport H2 and HOKA Hopara 2. This is excellent news for anyone who values shock absorption.

The ankle and heel strap’s interior is padded, which we appreciate.

Stability

Because the footbed is so narrow on these, we sometimes felt like we were teetering. Our tester’s personal preference is for a wider footbed that allows for toe splay and gripping. That said, hikers with narrow feet will probably do just fine in this regard. Our feet were certainly secure in the straps—so much so that we couldn’t move our toes. Again, this is a con for our tester but a pro for those with narrow feet.

The midsole is relatively stiff, resembling a hiking boot more than a trail running shoe. While this enhances the shoe’s stability, it reduces flexibility. If a flexible midsole is essential for you, consider skipping these. However, if you prefer not to feel roots and rocks beneath your feet, definitely add the Keen Rose to your potential shopping list.

Traction

The traction on the KEEN Rose sandals is on the low end of average. Judging by the outsole lug pattern and depth, these are not intended for rigorous hikes. They’re better suited for light day hikes and walking around town.

Though made of a sticky rubber, the outsole does not feature deep diamonds or triangles; rather, it has a shallow, scribble-like pattern. While we didn’t have the opportunity to take the Roses on technical terrain due to the poor fit for our feet, they performed as expected—just fine, nothing special—on the mild terrain (dirt, gravel, moderately rocky segments).

Durability

We don’t anticipate any issues with durability, other than perhaps the Velcro losing its effectiveness over time. The ankle strap is somewhat narrow, so it may wear down quicker than wider straps.

The midsole, known as KEEN.FUSION, actually comes with a guarantee. It’s entirely glue-free and, according to KEEN, won’t delaminate. Delamination occurs when the outsole of a shoe separates from the midsole and/or upper, which can happen to glued soles after a few hundred miles.

Weight & Packability

These are not the sandals you want to take as a second pair of shoes for water crossings or camping. They are heavy, weighing 9.52 ounces per shoe (nearly 20 ounces, or 1.25 pounds, per pair). While a pound doesn’t sound like much at first, it makes a significant difference when you’re planning to walk double-digit miles in a day.

In addition to their weight, the KEEN Roses have a thicker stack height and bulkier upper than other options, making them more challenging to pack. If anything, I’d recommend wearing them as your only pair of shoes and ditching a second pair. Since they fit securely and feature complete toe protection while retaining all the benefits of sandals, they can serve as an all-in-one option depending on the weather.

Ease of Use

For our tester, these are not easy to change in and out of, primarily because they are too narrow for her feet. Since there’s only one adjustment point, you have to slide your foot all the way in as-is: You can’t adjust the forefoot upper at all. Due to this singular adjustment point, it might be challenging for some hikers to achieve the desired fit. The sole adjustment mechanism is a narrow Velcro strap at the ankle; the heel strap is fixed, and the forefoot upper is, too.

For people with narrow feet, putting these on probably won’t be problematic. They should be able to slide their feet in and quickly adjust the ankle strap with ease.

Should You Buy the KEEN Rose Hiking Sandals?

The KEEN Rose hiking sandals are a solid choice for narrow-footed hikers seeking a snug, supportive fit. If you’ve struggled to find sandals that don’t slide around, these could be a game-changer. They’re great for light hikes, casual strolls, or as an everyday summer shoe, especially if you value shock absorption and toe protection.

That said, these sandals fall short for hikers with wider feet, those who prefer flexible midsoles, or anyone planning technical or long-distance treks. They’re on the heavier side and don’t pack down easily, which might make them a poor choice for backpackers needing a second pair of shoes. Ultimately, they are a quality option and a good investment for those with the right foot shape and needs.

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

If the Keen Roses don’t quite meet your needs, take a look at these similar hiking sandals, including a sibling shoe from KEEN.

Keen Newport H2 Review: For hikers seeking more versatility and a wider fit, the Newport H2 serves as an excellent alternative to the Rose. With a slightly sturdier outsole and multiple adjustment points, it is better equipped for technical trails and water crossings.

HOKA Hopara 2 Review: The HOKA Hopara 2 stands out for its improved traction and an upper similar to that of a true trail runner, but with excellent water drainage. Its foot protection and grippy outsole make it a great choice for technical terrain and long hikes, although it’s heavier than most sandals.

Ecco Yucatan Review:  Also great for narrow feet, the Ecco Yucatan provides more arch support and toe freedom than the Rose. These are a solid choice for hikers who require a secure fit but prefer their piggies to be in the open air.

Bottom Line

We value the Ecco Yucatan Offroad Hiking Sandals for their sturdy construction, soft yet secure straps, and three-point adjustability. They are ideal for hikers seeking ample support and stability, provided they suit your foot shape. Our tester experienced issues with the sandals’ narrowness, limiting their use to easy, short trails or around camp, where she could change them out if they became too uncomfortable. 

If you’re a hiker with narrow feet struggling to find sandals that aren’t heavy and awkward like wooden moccasins (we know you’re out there), the Yucatans may be a great option for you. While they can be expensive when not on sale, they’re worth the investment for the right foot. Besides being an excellent fit for narrow feet, they also offer essential support for hikers in need of extra ankle stability. The sidebar secures your feet, enabling comfort even when stepping at unusual angles, and the contoured footbeds provide a pleasant cradle for your foot feet. We have plenty of other options to consider in our hiking sandal gear guide.

How We Tested

We enjoyed a month-long crusade with the Ecco Yucatan, wearing them on various short hikes and around camps from Willamette National Forest, Oregon, to Los Padres National Forest, California. These sandals fit quite narrow, so our tester was limited in how long she could wear them on her neutral-width feet. However, we were still able to assess their performance on different types of terrain and in various trail situations.

Comfort

The Ecco Yucatan is ideal for hikers with narrow feet, high arches, and high insteps. Our tester has none of these traits, so she personally didn’t find the Yucatans very comfortable. It’s not a reflection on the shoes; they simply aren’t suitable for her feet or for anyone with wider feet (hers are medium/neutral). 

That said, we believe these hiking sandals are a boon for people with narrow feet, as we know it can be tough to find sandals—or any type of shoe for that matter—that provide a secure fit for slender feet. Even though these did not fit us well, we will give praise where praise is due: the upper of these sandals is so robust it feels almost like a sneaker, yet allows your toes to wiggle and breathe. The inside of the straps is so soft that, despite being tight on our tester, they didn’t cause any abrasions, blisters, or hot spots. 

They’re slightly padded, which enhances comfort. People who love cushioned hiking shoes will appreciate the Yucatan’s midsole. It’s plusher than most (a hard, rubbery midsole is typical of hiking sandals), and these offer a bit more give. Additionally, there’s an appealing contour in the footbed to prevent overpronation or over-supination and keep your heels in place.

Stability

These sandals are certainly not meant for the minimalist hiker. Their chunky design provides substantial support, but it does not offer much flexibility. Hikers, in particular, will notice (and either love or hate) the near-full-coverage upper, which features three independently adjustable Velcro straps. 

Unlike many other hiking sandals, the Yucatans cover much of the feet, creating a more secure fit than minimalist options. While some hikers may prefer an overlapping strap design for stability, we believe the exterior sidebar provides a locked-in feel. 

Additionally, the padded, contoured footbeds keep your feet secure even when stepping at odd angles. Regarding the midsole, it is plusher than many other options but not so soft that it compromises stability. We find it strikes a nice balance between shock absorption and energy return.

Traction

Of the dozens of pairs of hiking sandals we’ve tested, these have performed exceptionally well in terms of traction. Honestly, it makes our tester wish they fit her better because the tread is just that good. We’ve taken the Yucatans across several types of terrain, including talus/boulder fields, slickrock, pine straw-covered trails, slippery silt, packed dirt, and gravel. In no scenario has our tester felt unstable or anxious due to a lack of traction. 

The Yucatan is one of the very few hiking sandals about which we can truthfully say that. We were genuinely surprised about this because, upon examining the outsole, the lugs aren’t as deep as they are on some other options. 

So, visually, these don’t appear to be the strongest option, and they lack the coveted Vibram-branded outsoles found in some other choices. However, we believe the varied tread pattern and the security of the straps, which prevent our feet from sliding around, more than compensate for any shortcomings in that area.

Durability

The build quality of the Ecco Yucatan is impressive. With neoprene-lined adjustable straps, a molded EVA footbed with a microfiber lining, and leather components, it’s evident that a lot of thought went into the design of these hiking sandals. 

The components are high quality, and that’s obvious when you unbox the Yucatans and slip them on your feet. After several wears in various conditions, we haven’t seen any signs of wear and tear, except for some scuffing that is purely aesthetic. 

These also feature a durable stitching pattern on the straps, heel counter, and sidebar. Since the midsole is made from EVA foam, it will compress over time, much like running shoes do. Nevertheless, you should be able to get a solid 500 miles, at least, out of these sandals.

Weight & Packability

The Ecco Yucatan sandals are not packable in any hiking sense of the word. The pair weighs nearly 2 pounds, and the chunky design along with the thick midsole makes them nearly impossible—or, at the very least, highly inconvenient—to pack into any sort of hiking pack, whether for a day or an overnight trip. 

Our tester couldn’t find a suitable space for them in her Osprey Skarab 30-liter day pack; not even the stuff pocket in the front when it was full of gear, food, and water for a 14-miler. The sandals would have had to go in the bottom of the main compartment, which doesn’t make sense if the idea is to have them handy for water crossings. They’d make acceptable camp shoes, but there are more suitable and lightweight options available. However, if you prefer a single pair of shoes for the entire experience, including water crossings and camping, then the Yucatans could be a good option. We recommend considering a sneaker-like hybrid, such as the HOKA Hopara 2 or KEEN Newport H2.

Ease of Use

The Yucatans feature three independently adjustable Velcro straps, making them very easy to put on and take off—if your feet are on the narrow side, of course. With our tester’s neutral feet, she had to wiggle around to get into them and find a comfortable fit.

It wasn’t the worst experience, but we don’t recommend these for hikers with wide feet. They will be difficult (or impossible) to put on, and they won’t be comfortable even if you manage to wedge your feet into them.

Should You Buy the Ecco Yucatan Hiking Sandals?

The Ecco Yucatans are an ideal fit for hikers with narrow feet who seek sandals that provide considerable support. They’re not suitable for those with neutral feet, definitely not for wide feet, and they aren’t a good choice for minimalist hikers.

While they can be pricey when not on sale, we believe the Yucatans address a specific market gap and cater to individuals who often struggle to find well-fitting, quality hiking shoes.

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

If the Ecco Yucatans don’t seem quite right for you, consider these options, which we think are some of the best hiking sandals overall.

Teva Hurricane XLT2 Review: Similarly beefy, the Teva Hurricane XLT2s are better suited for wide feet. So, if you love the concept of the Yucatans but know they won’t fit your feet, the XLT2s are an excellent alternative. 

HOKA Hopara 2 Review: Arguably more shoe than sandal, the HOKA Hopara 2s function like sneakers while providing the same water drainage and breathability as sandals. The perforated mesh upper keeps your feet fresh and dry, and the toe bumper protects them from trail debris. 

KEEN Newport H2 Review: These are similar to the Hopara 2s in that they provide complete toe protection, excellent traction, and ample support. However, they are narrower, making them a better fit for hikers with slender feet.

Bottom Line

The Luna Mono Winged edition hiking sandals provide an outstanding combination of stability, support, and freedom for your feet. While they can be regarded as a minimalist sandal due to their zero-millimeter heel-to-toe drop, their solid stack height of 15 millimeters, which includes a 4-millimeter lug depth on the outsole, nudges them just slightly into the maximalist range. 

During testing, these secured a spot on our list of top-performing hiking sandals because of their exceptional array of features. Although three figures might seem pricey for sandals, we believe they are reasonably priced given their offerings.

How We Tested

We had the Luna Mono Winged sandals on our feet for about a month. We wore them on forest roads, well-maintained trails, poorly-maintained trails, and for hours on end while at camp.

Comfort

The straps! So smooth! So silky! We try to avoid speaking in superlatives, but the straps on the Luna Mono Winged sandals might truly be the best sandal straps we’ve ever had the pleasure of experiencing. Like the straps on most hiking sandals, these are made from a woven textile. We’re guessing it’s nylon or polyester, though the material isn’t disclosed on the website. 

Regardless, the best word to describe them is “supple.” They’re far softer than the straps on any other hiking sandals we’ve tried; as a result, they’re also much more flexible. We were able to pull the straps to create a tight, secure fit without experiencing any discomfort—no digging in, no rubbing, no chafing. 

All praises sung, we have one minor complaint. The wings (the plastic pieces holding the straps in place) on the inside of the sandal press against our tester’s foot. She doesn’t naturally pronate her feet (turn the arch downward), yet they still press against them, so this could be an issue for individuals who do heavily pronate. It wasn’t uncomfortable to the point of being painful, and our tester says she’ll still happily wear these sandals everywhere, but it is a bit distracting. 

The footbed is neutral and fits our tester’s foot well. People with very narrow feet might skip these; they’re most suitable for neutral to medium-wide feet.

Stability

Thanks to Luna’s single-strap adjustment system, it’s possible to achieve an incredibly secure fit, enhancing overall stability. While it may appear that there is only one adjustment point, these sandals actually feature a single continuous looped strap. You can essentially adjust them infinitely until you find a fit that works for you. 

The Mono Winged sandals feature a zero-drop midsole, yet they don’t necessarily feel like a minimalist sandal. This is due to the stack height being significantly thicker than that of a typical barefoot shoe, with a total stack height of 15 millimeters (11–millimeter midsole plus 4-millimeter outsole). Therefore, while there’s not much ground feel available, these sandals provide ample support and greater protection from sharp objects in the ground (hello, pokey rocks disguised by a layer of dirt). 

Despite its thickness, the midsole remains flexible enough to avoid feeling cumbersome or restrictive. A thinner stack height might provide more flexibility, but we found these to strike a good balance between protection, stability, and flexibility. The wings beneath the ankle bone, while slightly bothersome for our tester’s feet, help guard against over-pronation and over-supination, which could benefit those in need of a bit more ankle support.

Traction

We wore the Luna Mono sandals for several activities that presented varying conditions. First, we took them on a long walk along a dirt road in a central California forest. The road surface featured silty segments, fine gravel, and even some stretches of exposed, chunky rock. The incline was moderate, never exceeding about 10%. We didn’t encounter any traction issues on this walk; the sandals performed excellently in these dry conditions. 

We also wore them for a day out at camp in a national forest, which involved a lot of relaxed walking and exploring, much of it on barely-there trails or no trail at all. The surfaces we encountered included somewhat deep dirt (2 to 3 inches; very soft), a pine straw-covered forest floor, bare rock, and gravel. We even wore the sandals to scramble up some small boulders for an epic sunset view. 

Throughout all of this, the sandals provided excellent traction and caused us no issues. On another day, we wore the Lunas on a short but steep summit hike. This trail—1.2 miles and 1,300 feet to the summit—did present some slippage. It wasn’t significant, likely because the trail surface was fairly packed and there were no scree sections, but it made us hesitant to take them on any trails more difficult than that.

Durability

We expect these to last a long time. The 11-millimeter midsole is dense and resistant to compression. The outsole features a 4-millimeter lug depth, ensuring the tread can withstand heavy use across varied terrain. 

The footbed, however, may wear down and lose its texture prematurely since there isn’t much to start with: just a very light hexagonal pattern in the rubber. 

The straps, tightly woven and flexible, seem sufficiently durable. There are a few plastic components (the buckles and the wings on each side), and plastic is always prone to breakage, especially given the nature of outdoor activities.

Weight & Packability

Weighing in at 11.8 ounces per pair, the Luna Winged Mono sandals are among the lightest options across the dozens we’ve tested. They are certainly light enough to serve as a second pair of shoes, although their thicker stack height can make them difficult to fit into narrow compartments.

We recommend dividing them into separate compartments or attaching them to the outside of your pack.

Ease of Use

It may take you some time to find the ideal fit with these sandals, and you might feel frustrated with the single-strap/multi-adjustment point design. But persevere and keep adjusting, because once you discover your perfect fit, you may never buy another hiking sandal again. 

Initially, we found the system cumbersome and annoying, but after adjusting the straps a few times, we discovered a fit that felt both ultra-secure and ultra-comfortable. In many other hiking sandals, you typically have to compromise between these two aspects, but that’s not the case with the Luna Mono Winged edition. 

Once you’ve found your ideal fit, putting them on and taking them off is easy. All you need to do is loosen the strap on the midfoot buckle to wiggle your feet in and slide them out. Just make sure to do the fitting part before heading out on the trail, or you’ll have a bad time. (P.S. You can actually move the buckle around, too, and place it in the most comfortable spot for you.)

Should You Buy the Luna Mono Winged Edition?

The Luna Mono Winged hiking sandals are a perfect fit for hikers looking to transition to barefoot-inspired shoes without diving in completely. They also serve as an excellent option for any hiker who prefers a zero-drop midsole but seeks more support and protection than typical barefoot sandals provide.

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

We’ve tested dozens of hiking sandals, and the following are some of our favorites that have similar qualities to the Luna Mono Winged edition. 

Teva Original Universal Review: These have a similar stack height and midsole compared to the Luna Mono Winged, but the outsole is less rugged and is not as suitable for technical adventures. The strap design is also somewhat different, featuring three independently adjustable Velcro closures (as opposed to Luna’s continuous loop system). 

Earth Runner Alpha Review: Perhaps the most barefoot-like of barefoot sandals, the Earth Runner Alphas offer an incredible level of connection to the ground. These are for you if you want to feel the earth beneath your feet while protecting your skin from trail surfaces. 

Xero Shoes Z-Trail EV Review: Another ultra-barefoot-style option, the Z-Trail EVs are incredibly lightweight and feel almost like wearing nothing. You might even forget they’re on. They’re definitely worth considering if that’s the vibe you’re going for.

Bottom Line

The KEEN Newport H2 hiking sandals can be aptly described as “amphibious.” Ideal for hikers in need of durability, this adaptable sandal-sneaker hybrid performs well in both wet and dry environments. Featuring a quick-toggle bungee lace system and a grippy outsole, they ensure a secure fit and excellent traction, even on steep or slippery terrain. The thick midsole provides remarkable energy return, making these sandals a great option for those who prioritize comfort on extended hikes.

However, the Newport H2 may not be suitable for hikers with wider feet because of its snug fit, and the heel strap can become uncomfortable during prolonged use. Weighing close to 11 ounces per shoe, they are heavier and bulkier compared to standard hiking sandals, which limits their practicality for those seeking a lightweight, packable option. Nevertheless, their capability to serve as both hiking and water shoes makes them an appealing choice for diverse outdoor adventures. You can see more options in our women’s hiking sandal gear guide.

How We Tested

We’ve worn the KEEN Newport H2 for over a dozen trail miles during several short hikes to evaluate them for various performance metrics. We consider comfort, stability, durability, traction, ease of use, and weight and packability when testing hiking sandals.

Comfort

Our tester didn’t love the KEEN Newport H2 regarding fit and comfort. They felt a bit too narrow for her feet (and she has a pretty neutral width), both through the midfoot and in the toe box, even with the bungee laces adjusted as loosely as possible. Someone with narrower feet may want to consider these, as they’d likely provide a more secure fit than many other hiking sandals. 

The heel strap began to dig into her Achilles tendon after about 1.5 miles, and it really started to hurt after approximately three miles of hiking. It reached a point where our tester was frequently stopping to readjust her feet and the straps to relieve the pressure. 

However, it’s not all bad. We really like the midsoles on the Newport H2s: they’re on the thicker side and are quite rigid, but not in a bad way. They don’t absorb shock like sneakers, but they provide a great deal of energy return, which makes us feel light and bouncy on our feet. 

We wore these with socks and without socks; without them, we noticed a blister forming where the heel strap pressed into the Achilles on both heels. Yet, despite the tightness of the heel strap, we had ample room between the ends of our toes and the front of the shoe, which we were thankful for. We found the arch support on the Newport H2s to be greater and more comfortable than similar styles, such as the HOKA Hopara 2 and KEEN Rose.

Stability

You won’t find many hiking sandals that provide more stability than the Keen Newport H2s. Since these are sandal-sneaker hybrid shoes, they fit much like trail running shoes in that they are snug, secure, and protective.

For our tester (who has neutral feet), they are almost too snug, so we wouldn’t recommend them to individuals with wide feet. The midsole is rigid, which enhances stability but diminishes ground feel. You won’t feel rocks beneath your feet in the Newport H2s. 

The upper is flexible enough to permit full flexion and extension of the toe joints, yet snug enough to keep your feet secure even when moving downhill at fast paces. 

Notably, due to their snug fit, these could be a good option for people whose feet tend to get very sweaty. We wore these on a warm day, and despite our feet becoming quite sweaty, they did not slip around in the sandal.

Traction

We wore the KEEN Newport H2 sandals on various trail surfaces, including dry, packed dirt, loose sand, gravel, and chunkier rocks. We also took them up and down steep, gravelly inclines on forest roads. They performed well in every scenario, even on the steeper, slippery segments. We even ran down significant declines and didn’t experience any issues with slipping or sliding.

Additionally, we wore these during a few on-and-off rainy days at camp, where we spent a lot of time walking around in the dirt and mud to cook, play with our dog, and work out. We are thoroughly impressed with their traction, especially considering the outsole lugs aren’t particularly deep. The rubber is just that sticky!

Durability

These are certainly among the top options for durability in hiking sandals. The outsole and toe bumper are constructed from dense rubber, while the upper features a combination of suede and woven textiles. 

All fabric components incorporate double-stitching to reduce the risk of fraying or loose stitches. Additionally, the bungee laces are thick and durable against fraying. 

The only issue we foresee is with the plastic lace toggle. It’s a fairly delicate piece, so with continued use, it could break. So far, however, we have encountered no problems.

Weight & Packability

We don’t consider these shoes packable, and we don’t think most hikers—especially backpackers—would either. Weighing nearly 11 ounces per shoe, they are among the heaviest sandals we have ever worn. 

In addition to their weight, they are quite bulky and would be cumbersome to pack as a second pair of shoes. However, the intent behind the shoes is to eliminate the need for packing a water shoe entirely.

If it’s warm enough outside, you can simply wear these KEENs for all wet and dry segments without needing a second pair. So, while not packable, they could ultimately help you reduce your pack weight in this way.

Ease of Use

Our tester found the Newport H2 quite difficult to put on and take off. Because there is no adjustment point on the heel, she had to loosen the bungee laces all the way, and even then she struggled to slide her feet into the sandals.

It was somewhat of a battle, she admits, and with wet or sweaty feet, it was even worse. People with narrower feet may not have an issue sliding their feet through the somewhat small ankle collars.

Should You Buy the KEEN Newport H2?

If you’re a narrow-footed hiker looking for a durable, versatile sandal that performs well on both wet and dry terrain, the KEEN Newport H2 is worth considering. Its amphibious design eliminates the need to pack separate water shoes, and its excellent traction and energy-returning midsole make it suitable for various trail conditions.

However, hikers with wide feet or those prioritizing lightweight, packable footwear may want to look elsewhere. For those who value stability, durability, and a secure fit, the Newport H2 is a reliable investment.

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

If the KEEN Newport H2 doesn’t quite meet your needs, there are several similar hiking sandals to choose from. These alternatives offer unique features and advantages for hikers with different priorities and foot types.

Keen Rose Review: Even narrower than the Newport H2, this lighter, more feminine alternative uses a simple Velcro strap closure system (as opposed to the Newport H2’s bungee lace with toggle). While not as rugged, it performs well on mild trails and offers sufficient protection for light hiking, casual outings, or water activities.

Ecco Yucatan Review: The Ecco Yucatan is a classic hiking sandal known for its all-day comfort and impressive arch support. Its three adjustable straps ensure a customized fit, making it a great choice for neutral to narrow feet. Ideal for warm-weather day hikes, it’s versatile enough for urban exploration and outdoor adventures alike.

HOKA Hopara 2 Review: The HOKA Hopara 2 blends hiking shoe stability with sandal breathability. Its closed-toe design and aggressive outsole lugs excel on most trails, while the cushioned midsole offers exceptional energy return, especially when bounding downhill. This hybrid sandal is perfect for those needing extra protection and traction on challenging, wet, or rocky paths.

Bottom Line

The HOKA Hopara 2 is the perfect blend of sneaker and sandal. Unlike conventional water shoes, these waterproof and protective footwear is designed to manage rocky paths and steep descents just as effectively as they navigate muddy trails and stream crossings. Featuring HOKA’s distinctive chunky midsole, the Hopara 2 meets the needs of hikers seeking better support and cushioning compared to standard hiking sandals.

The robust midsole and sneaker-inspired upper enhance their suitability for rock-hopping while preventing most trail debris from entering.In our testing, these performed exceptionally well on most trail conditions, such as dry dirt, gravel, and bare rock.

However, they had difficulty providing traction on extremely silty surfaces. Also, while we truly appreciate the spacious footbed and toe box, they may not be suitable for hikers with narrow feet. Despite these minor drawbacks, the Hopara 2s firmly secured a spot in our list of top-performing hiking sandals after evaluating them across various trail surfaces.

How We Tested

We’ve worn the HOKA Hopara 2s for over 20 miles, traversing forest road walks, single-track trails, and road runs through the mountains. While wearing them, we continually assess their performance in six key areas: comfort, stability, traction, durability, weight and packability, and ease of use.

Comfort

Overall, these shoes felt incredibly comfortable and very bouncy, providing lots of energy return, which makes them excellent for faster-paced trail activities such as quick hikes, jogs, and trail runs. The midsole is somewhat stiff, definitely more so than a typical trail shoe or what would be considered an “approach shoe” (i.e., light hikers or trail runners). However, that didn’t bother us, even when running downhill. 

During our initial break-in period, we noticed a bit of a hot spot starting to appear after about two miles with socks on. No blisters formed after the subsequent 6+ miles on the same day, even with several of those miles being sockless. We were thankful to discover that the ankle collar of the shoes didn’t irritate our skin at all; it’s actually quite soft and flexible. We also experienced no issues with the open area on the heel causing hot spots or abrasions. 

Wearing relatively thick socks (Darn Tough mid-cushion hiking socks), our tester, who has fairly neutral feet, found the shoe width perfect. The toe box and forefoot felt roomy, yet not overly spacious. Our toes had ample room during downhill segments, even while running. We noticed they felt a bit loose without socks, and the adjustment mechanism didn’t provide a snug fit. Individuals with narrower feet may not have a good experience with the Hopara 2s.

Stability

This is not a minimalist shoe, that’s for sure. The midsole is thick and has a 5-millimeter heel-to-toe drop. Even though the midsole is thick (especially for a sandal), it is not plush. It’s quite hard, actually, and does not absorb much shock at all. The upside is that this stiff midsole is bouncy and provides excellent energy return, which could be beneficial for individuals who sometimes feel like the terrain is a magnet to their feet. 

Don’t mistake bounciness for instability, though: we found these to handle a variety of terrain very well. We took them over gravel, scree, large rocks, dirt, and grass, and we didn’t once encounter a lack of rigidity or over-plushness. 

Due to the thicker midsole and full upper, the Hopara 2 definitely feels more like a sneaker than a sandal, which can be a positive attribute in certain scenarios. For instance, we believe these are an excellent option for warmer weather and more rugged hiking that a typical sandal can’t handle. Additionally, because of their sneaker-like structure, our ankles feel much more stable in these than in traditional hiking sandals.

Traction

The Hoka Hopara 2 excelled at moderate angles on dry dirt, grassy areas, and bare rock. However, during our testing, we took them up scree slopes where they did not perform well.

Descending a short but steep scree face, our tester ended up having to scoot on her butt and use her hands for balance. We were somewhat surprised, as the outsole lugs are relatively deep and the tread pattern is robust—similar to that of a trail running shoe. This left us wondering if the lack of traction was due to the outsole material, which feels more plasticky than rubbery. 

Durability

After more than 15 miles of use, we believe the Hoka Hopara 2 will be among the most durable hiking sandals we’ve tried. The mesh upper is quite flexible while being tightly woven—almost plasticky, similar to the midsole. 

The midsole and outsole are tough, making it difficult to flex and extend the shoe with your hands fully. While this may not be considered a positive trait in every context, it contributes to the shoe’s durability. 

While we haven’t noticed any issues yet, we could see the soft, stretchy knit section of the upper (ankle collar area) fraying or losing its elasticity over time. It’s made of a softer woven material and is only slightly elastic, which raises concerns when we consider stretching the ankle collar to slip the shoes on each time.

Weight & Packability

At 20.8 ounces for the pair, the Hopara 2 is among the heaviest hiking sandals we’ve ever worn—don’t even bother packing these as a second pair of shoes. That said, we’re not entirely sure we can label this as a clear negative, given that the Hopara 2 is a hybrid sneaker-sandal. It’s reasonable to expect that they are heavier than traditional hiking sandals. 

In a way, we can view this as a positive aspect, as it suggests that you don’t need to pack a pair of sandals. What we mean is, these are well-suited for rugged hiking and water crossings, allowing you to wear just one pair and forgo the need for additional sandals, potentially saving weight in the end.

Ease of Use

For the most part, the Hopara is easy to get on and off. Our tester struggled a bit with the quick-lace mechanism: the toggle got stuck a couple of times. You need to press the sides of the toggle in a specific way for the mechanism to operate smoothly. The Velcro strap on the heel is simple to use and also facilitates sliding the shoes on and off easily.

One important thing to note: We do not recommend these for very silty terrain. Our tester took these up a short scramble that consisted mostly of a sandy surface with loose, small rocks. Many dirt particles and several small pebbles ended up in the shoes, and because they are unlike traditional sandals, she couldn’t just shake her foot around to dislodge the pebbles. She had to take the shoes off to dump them out. With socks, this isn’t an issue, but it becomes rather annoying when wearing the Hopara 2s without socks.`

Should You Buy the HOKA Hopara 2?

The HOKA Hopara 2 is a solid choice for hikers seeking an all-in-one shoe suitable for wet-weather hikes or water crossings. The hybrid design of these shoes eliminates the need to carry a pair of hiking sandals and switch out of hiking shoes for wet sections.

The Hopara 2s also offer an excellent trail running experience in warm conditions. Even with socks, they allow the feet to breathe more than typical trail running shoes while providing the same level of protection for the toes and soles. Although they’re not inexpensive, they can effectively replace two pairs of shoes (sandals and tennis shoes), making them a great value. 

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

The Hopara 2 may be a niche hiking sandal, but if you’re into it, there are some similar options worth considering. 

Keen Newport H2 Review: Like the Hopara 2s, which offer complete toe protection and a sneaker-like feel, the Keen Newport H2s may better suit narrower feet due to their slender footbed and tapered toe box.

Keen Rose Review: Another similar pick from Keen, the Rose sandals are slightly lower profile and feature a more sandal-like—versus sneaker-like—midsole. They still provide a secure fit and total toe protection.

Ecco Yucatan Review: The Yucatan Eccos provide a similar midsole feel to the Hopara 2s, as they are rigid and sturdy, and offer a secure sensation, thanks to the sandal’s upper that cradles the outside of the foot. However, they are open-toe, so you lose that protection (but gain freedom for your piggies.) 

Bottom Line

If foot freedom is what you’re after, the Earth Runner Alpha Adventure Sandals might be the perfect choice for hiking. If you love a flip-flop style sandal and seek foot freedom, the Earth Runner Alpha Adventure Sandals may be the ideal option for you. A close runner-up to our top pick for ultralight sandals, the Alphas feel almost like wearing nothing—as long as the toe thong doesn’t bother you like it did our tester. They also offer incredible connectedness to the earth beneath your feet and excellent traction on nearly all surfaces despite their lightweight design.  

You may think you’re not getting much footwear for the cost (as there are more robust hiking sandals at a similar price), but the price reflects the design rather than the materials. This design lets your feet breathe, flex, splay, and strengthen.

How We Tested

Due to our tester experiencing significant discomfort while wearing the Earth Runner Alphas (to her disappointment, as she wanted to love the sandals), we could only test them for a brief period. Our tester wore them during a casual 3-mile hike, as well as for a few hours around her campsite in a national forest.

Comfort

We wanted to love these sandals, but our tester did not enjoy her experience with the Earth Runner Alphas; in fact, she couldn’t bear to wear them for more than a 3-mile hike on easy to moderate terrain. It might just be that her feet are incompatible with the sandal design, as she began experiencing aches the moment she put them on. 

The toe thong strap is just as wide as the other straps, which really made us wonder if anyone actually has a gap that large between their big and middle toes. Our tester tried repeatedly to adjust it, but the strap kept digging painfully into the inside of her big toe. 

It’s important to note that we tested the Performance Laces, which are Earth Runner’s most robust laces designed for heavy use. Perhaps another lace style—one that is more flexible and/or thinner, like the Classic Lifestyle Laces—might have worked better for our tester. 

Other parts of the shoe felt fine. We really love the canvas footbed material. It’s soft on the bottom of the feet yet grippy, so you don’t slide around. Our tester didn’t get too sweaty on the hike she took in Los Padres National Forest in California, but we imagine that on a very hot day, this material would soak up sweat to prevent your feet from slipping. That’s great for grip but leaves us wondering about the smell after many uses.

Stability

These are truly minimalist hiking sandals with a zero-drop sole and a total stack height of 10.5 millimeters. If you want a lot of ground feel, these are the hiking sandals for you. Although our tester experienced some discomfort while wearing these, she thoroughly enjoyed walking over various terrain features, particularly rocks jutting out from the trail, just to feel the earth beneath her feet (without all of the pricking and tickling that happens on bare feet). 

When people say they love the way barefoot-style shoes make them feel, this is what they’re talking about: Despite the minimalist construction, they feel sturdy yet freeing beneath the feet.

The footbed is also designed to mimic the natural shape of human feet (which many of us have lost by wearing narrow, closed shoes), and our tester felt like her feet had a breath of fresh air when her toes were able to splay across the wide footbed without extending over the sides. There’s no heel cup on these, so we don’t recommend them for anyone looking for contouring or cradling of the feet.

Earth Runner Alphas are definitely not the right hiking sandals for those seeking cushioning and shock absorption—these offer neither—but they excel for minimalist hikers.

Traction

Because our tester experienced significant discomfort due to the toe straps, she regrettably could not take them across a variety of terrains. She wore them for about three miles on a mild dirt trail covered in fallen pine straw and small to medium rocks, as well as around her camp, which included dirt, sand, pine straw, and some gravel, for about another hour. In each of these situations, the Alphas performed well—indeed, they excelled. 

We didn’t encounter a single issue with traction, which actually surprised us given the lug depth and pattern. The Alphas don’t feature the most robust outsole we’ve ever seen on hiking sandals, but trusty Vibram has done it again: these are sticky. That said, our tester indicates she wouldn’t take them on any grades above 15% unless the terrain is very packed (i.e., not scree, silt, or similar). However, she notes that she personally wouldn’t take any sandals on grades that steep, so that’s not a criticism of Earth Runner specifically.

Durability

The impressive construction of the laces gives us hope for their longevity. Made from a hydrophobic polyester core with a mil-spec nylon wrap, they are designed to last. We know, we know, that’s some jargon: The long and short of it is that the laces are durable. However, this does mean they sacrifice a bit of flexibility, as our tester’s big toes can vouch for. 

We have a lot of faith in Vibram outsoles and expect them to last, although the lugs themselves aren’t the deepest. They may wear down faster than the lugs on a maximalist sandal, but that isn’t unexpected. We also wonder about the canvas footbed. While canvas is a durable textile, it doesn’t match the durability of rubber, so we can foresee the footbed developing abrasions and eventually holes in high-pressure areas, like the heel.

Weight & Packability

Weighing in at under 8 ounces per pair (yes, per pair, not per shoe), these are among the lightest hiking sandals we have ever tested. To all our ultra-lighters, these are for you. Even better: they are flat and thin, with a stack height of just 10.5 millimeters (9-millimeter outsole plus 1.5-millimeter footbed), resulting in a mere width of 21 millimeters for the pair. 

They can easily slide into thin pack compartments or be secured on the exterior using your pack’s integrated straps, depending on its design. Our tester was even able to fit these into her REI Co-op Trail 5 Waist Pack.

Ease of Use

The initial adjustment is somewhat challenging if you’re not used to the style of these sandals. The way the heel strap wraps around and inserts into the buckle is a bit unconventional and can take quite a while to figure out (it did for our tester, but she admits she’s not the world’s greatest tinkerer).

Once you’ve got your fit, though, you’re good to go. However, if you accidentally remove the heel strap from the buckle completely, you’ll have to re-lace it, which could be annoying and time-consuming if this happens on the trail.

Should You Buy the Earth Runner Alpha?

If you’re explicitly looking for a barefoot-inspired hiking sandal and aren’t bothered by a toe thong, then yes, buy the Earth Runner Alpha Sandals.

Although they may seem pricey due to their exceptionally minimal design, what they lack in material, they more than make up for in experience. Those who want their feet to breathe and their toes to splay will not be disappointed.

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

The Earth Runner Alphas are far from the only barefoot sandals to choose from. Among top-performing hiking sandals, here are several picks to consider. 

Xero Shoes Z-Trail EV Review: A favorite among our testers, the Z-Trail EVs offer the same coveted barefoot feeling, but without the cumbersome strap between your toes. We appreciate their soft, flexible footbed and 5,000-mile sole warranty. 

Luna Mono Winged Review: These are a great option for those just beginning their barefoot journey. Although they have a zero-millimeter heel-to-toe drop, the Luna Mono Winged edition sandals feature a much thicker and more supportive midsole with a stack height of 15 millimeters. 

Astral Webber Review: We recommend the Webbers for anyone looking to try zero-drop shoes on easy outings. They are perfect for wearing around town, at the beach, and on mostly flat walks, providing a chance to begin strengthening your feet in comfortable settings.

Bottom Line

These hiking sandals are for you if you want to wear shoes without the sensation of actually wearing them. Our tester was amazed the moment she slipped her feet into the Xero Shoes Z-Trail EVs: It felt like getting out of a sweaty sports bra after a long, hot hike. These sandals provide complete foot freedom while protecting the soles of your feet from rough trail surfaces. 

The Z-Trail EVs are barefoot-inspired shoes, so we don’t recommend them for anyone who requires ankle or arch support or any assistance with stability. You may want to look for something else in our best hiking sandals guide. However, if grounding is what you seek, we’re not sure you can beat these. Additionally, they’re very reasonably priced and come with an impressive two-year, 5,000-mile sole warranty.

How We Tested

Besides wearing the Z-Trail EVs for many days at camp, which included a lot of walking on different unpaved surfaces, we took them on several national forest hikes, ranging from well-kept to overgrown. Over several weeks, we assessed them for comfort, stability, durability, and more.

Comfort

Putting on the Xero Shoes Z-Trail EV sandals after wearing boots or sneakers feels like unbuttoning your jeans after Thanksgiving dinner. With the wide footbed, impressively flexible midsole, and soft woven straps, wearing these barely feels like wearing shoes at all. Our tester experienced a minor issue with her heels not quite reaching the heel counter, but it didn’t end up bothering her while hiking. 

Additionally, our tester found the rubber wing on the forefoot (where the strap is held in place) to be slightly awkward due to its large size; however, it doesn’t cause any discomfort. The footbed material is soft and absorbent, preventing your feet from slipping around while possibly leading to perma-stink over time. 

Her medium-width feet fit well in the Z-Trail EVs, and thanks to the adjustment system, these sandals can accommodate most foot widths. However, individuals with very narrow feet might find the footbed slightly clunky due to its width.

Stability

The Z-Trail EVs, while extremely comfortable, are not stable hiking sandals. It feels unjust to criticize them for that, however, when the whole point is to liberate your feet from the confines of typical shoes. There’s no doubt about it: these are not meant for hikers who require support and stability. 

The midsole is extremely thin and very flexible, and the slender straps secure your feet just enough to keep them in place. The minimal heel counter provides a slight element of security, but it shouldn’t be relied upon in challenging trail conditions. Your muscles and joints must do the work in these sandals—there are no crutches built into the design. 

We express all of this in the most favorable way possible. We adore the Z-Trail EVs; of all the hiking sandals we’ve tested, these make our feet feel the freest. 

However, those who struggle with ankle stability, require arch support, or simply want a super-secure fit should avoid these shoes. Even for individuals looking to transition to barefoot shoes, we suggest beginning that journey with something more supportive.

Traction

Xero had a great idea when designing the lug pattern on the Z-Trail EVs. The outsole incorporates five distinct zones with textured chevron lugs of varying sizes. The larger lugs effectively dig into the trail surface, while the smaller ones excel at providing traction on bare rock faces. 

However, those same small lugs tend to collect tiny bits of trail debris between them, which reduces overall traction when those gaps are filled. Despite this, we haven’t encountered any major issues hiking in the EVs across packed dirt, small and large gravel, bare rock (wet and dry), and pine straw-covered ground. 

On some steeper grades, our tester has had to use her hands for assistance; the traction alone wasn’t good enough to prevent slipping. However, she didn’t actually experience any slips or falls in these sandals.

Durability

Notably, Xero Shoes provides an impressive 5,000-mile sole warranty on the Trail EV sandals (and other models). The company also offers an industry-leading manufacturer’s warranty of two years.

Yes, you can wear your Xero sandals for a full two years, and if something breaks that isn’t due to misuse (such as leaving your sandals exposed to direct sunlight, which can warp the foam soles), Xero will repair or replace them. 

The sole warranty specifically covers Xero’s patented FeelTrue sole if your soles wear down to less than 1 millimeter thick at the ball or heel of the foot (not the edge) before you reach 5,000 miles. If that occurs, they’ll replace the shoes with the same style you originally purchased, for free. After learning that, you probably won’t be surprised that we see no signs of wear on our Z-Trail EVs after thorough testing.

Weight & Packability

Weighing just 8.3 ounces for the pair, the Z-Trail EVs are among the lightest sandals we’ve ever worn. Seriously: They almost feel non-existent, especially since Xero eliminated the toe thong design, meaning there’s no fabric wedged between your toes. 

They are also slender, boasting an 11-millimeter stack height and zero-millimeter heel-to-toe drop. This makes them ideal for packing as camp or creek-crossing shoes on long day hikes and multi-night backpacking trips. Additionally, they’re light enough to be clipped to the exterior of your pack without swinging around or being very noticeable at all.

Ease of Use

Like many hiking sandals, you’ll need a few minutes for the initial adjustment to get the sandals suited to your feet. After that, everything’s easy-peasy.

The heel strap adjusts independently, while the ankle, midfoot, and forefoot straps are continuous and do not adjust independently. Changing one strap will affect another, but with a little experimentation, you’ll discover your perfect fit.

Should You Buy the Xero Shoes Z-Trail EV?

If you seek a barefoot-like experience and want to feel the ground beneath your feet: Yes, yes, and yes again.

If you need ankle support, arch support, or any other stability from your shoes: Pass and opt for something with a sturdier design. Even if you’re looking to transition from bulky, traditional shoes to barefoot-inspired options, it may be best to start with something more supportive, like the Teva Original Universal or Luna Mono Winged.

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

While we think the Xero Shoes Z-Trail EVs are some of the best hiking sandals available, there are plenty of other good options to choose from.

Earth Runner Alpha Review: These are similar in that they are also minimalistic. They feature a zero-drop sole and a total stack height of less than 11 millimeters, and they also weigh under 8 ounces for the pair. If you’re looking for a barefoot shoe with a toe thong strap, you might really like these.

Luna Mono Winged Review: The Mono Winged sandals smoothly transition from traditional, chunky sandals to minimalist options. Although they feature a zero-drop sole, the total stack height between the sole and lugs measures 15 millimeters. This design makes them sturdier and more supportive than the Z-Trail EVs. 

Astral Webber Review: Another zero-drop option, the Astral Webbers provide better support for our feet than the Z-Trail EVs, thanks to their contoured footbed. However, the traction isn’t the best, so reserve these for light hikes, strolls around town, and water activities.

Bottom Line

The Teva Original Universal is an excellent option for anyone looking for a lightweight, adaptable sandal suitable for various light outdoor activities and everyday use. At just 11 ounces per pair, these sandals are highly portable, making them a great secondary option for water crossings or as camp shoes. The dual Velcro straps facilitate easy on-and-off and adjustment, guaranteeing a comfortable, secure fit each time.

While their traction and support are not robust enough for rugged terrain or steep, slippery surfaces, they’re some of the best hiking sandals for mild trails, sand, grass, and gravel. The neutral footbed and moderate midsole support may not be ideal for individuals requiring substantial arch support or those with very wide feet. However, these sandals are durable and flexible, maintaining their quality even after years of heavy use. Priced reasonably, the Original Universal provides great value for adventurers seeking an “everything sandal” that excels for errands, river outings, and light hikes.

How We Tested

Our tester has been wearing Original Universals for several years, selecting them for warm-weather days around town, relaxing walks, and moderate hikes in warm or wet conditions. She subjected them to a focused round of testing for this review, assessing them against six key performance metrics: comfort, stability, durability, traction, ease of use, and packability.

Comfort

Our lead tester has worn Teva Original Universals for years; she honestly can’t say how many miles she’s logged in them—well over 200, at least. She has used them for various activities, including hikes, neighborhood or city walks, running errands, a day at the beach, paddling, and yard work or gardening. 

Their overall performance has led us to choose them as a go-to “everything” sandal. The main reason is that they are incredibly comfortable and lightweight. Plus, the straps are pliable and never dig into our skin—not even with a brand-new pair. 

The midsole has a moderate width, and while it doesn’t provide the most robust arch support, it is supple and supportive enough for light activities. The footbed is neutral; it may not be suitable for individuals with very wide feet, but for those with narrow feet, the Velcro forefoot strap can accommodate any slack in the fit.

Stability

The midsole on the Teva Original Universals has a moderately supportive structure with minimal arch support. They’re not quite minimalist sandals, but they might feel unsupportive if you’re accustomed to a more robust, rigid shoe, such as the Ecco Yucatan or even the Chaco Z/1 Classic. 

As far as terrain is concerned, the Original Universals are best suited for mild trail surfaces. We’ve found them to lack stability on “chunky” terrain, such as larger, sharper rocks and river rocks. For that reason, we don’t love them for challenging water crossings. We wouldn’t recommend them for, say, The Narrows in Zion, where you’ll be stepping over large, slippery rocks under water. 

On dirt, gravel, wet and dry sand, and grass, they perform exceptionally well, and we appreciate feeling a stronger connection to the ground in them compared to sturdier sandals.

Traction

The tread on these is mild; the triangle-shaped lugs are only about 2 millimeters deep. The Teva brand itself states they are best suited for around-town wear and water activities, though we would give them a bit more credit than that. 

They grip the ground just fine on drier, relatively packed surfaces, like sand, dirt, and gravel; however, the Original Universals definitely struggle on scree slopes and any silty surfaces at an angle. We’ve found that they have respectable traction up to moderate angles on bare rock. We wouldn’t feel comfortable wearing them for steep slickrock sections.

Durability

Our tester has owned a pair of Original Universals for three years and has put them through the ringer with daily wear for errands, yard work, and walking the dog, as well as various recreational outings, from paddleboarding to hiking. They’re holding up well, without any frays in the straps. The Velcro still works perfectly, too, despite being regularly exposed to sand and dirt.

Weight & Packability

Weighing just 5.5 ounces per shoe, the Original Universals are incredibly packable as a second pair of sandals for stream crossings or as camp shoes. Their low profile and flexibility make them easy to pack, even when you’re tight on space.

However, as we mentioned before, I can’t confidently recommend these for water crossings that are more treacherous than a shallow creek or small brook. We personally wouldn’t feel comfortable fording a river in them due to the lack of substantial tread and somewhat minimal security. As camp shoes, though? 100%.

Ease of Use

These sandals couldn’t be easier to use. Thanks to the dual Velcro straps, they are incredibly easy to put on and take off, making it hassle-free to do so multiple times on the trail. They’re also quick to readjust, and you don’t even need to sit down or remove your pack to make a swift adjustment to the straps.

Should You Buy the  Teva Original Universal?

If you’re in the market for an affordable, lightweight sandal that’s easy to pack and perfect for light outdoor activities, the Teva Original Universal is a fantastic choice. Durable and versatile, it is a reliable option for everything from moderate hikes to city walks.

However, if you need a sandal with exceptional traction, arch support, or rugged terrain capabilities, you may need to look elsewhere. For those seeking an everyday adventure companion at a low price, though, the Teva Original Universal is hard to beat.

What Other Women’s Hiking Sandals Should You Consider?

The Teva Original Universals are some of the most versatile hiking sandals. In case you’re looking for something similar, but perhaps a bit more rugged, consider these alternatives.

Teva Hurricane XLT2 Review: Essentially a mightier version of the Original Universal, the TEVA Hurricane XLT2 features a thicker, more rigid midsole, a larger heel-to-toe drop, and deeper outsole lugs for enhanced traction. 

Chaco Z/1 Classic Review: Chacos, specifically the Z/1 Classics, are a staple for adventurers around the globe. Like the Teva Original Universals, these feature a simple nylon strap design, but the midsole is stiffer and more supportive. The Z/1 Classics also provide better traction than the Original Universals. Instead of Velcro, the Z/1 Classics use a single-bar buckle closure with a single-strap adjustment system.

Luna Mono Winged Edition Review: For something minimalist yet sturdy, try the Luna Mono Winged sandals. Inspired by the barefoot movement, these feature a 15-millimeter stack height for support but maintain a zero-millimeter heel-to-toe drop to encourage natural foot flexion and movement. They also utilize a thong-style strap rather than Teva’s forefoot strap.